TWR Nov 2026_ebook - Flipbook - Page 9
REGULATION|REPORT
T
he fizz of excitement that surrounded the publication of Sir Jon
Cunliffe’s water reform recommendations in mid 2025 has gone a bit
flat as we edge towards the end of 2026.
That’s courtesy of ongoing delay and now
– post the change of PM – genuine uncertainty about the direction of travel.
But the wheels of regulation keep turning. Watchdogs are busy behind the scenes
trying to operate more hand-in-glove
with each other, and work has begun on
PR29. Ahead of the formal methodology
next year, we are promised a ‘PR29 Charter’ this autumn: a high level statement of
intent or, as Ofwat chief executive Chris
Walters recently described it, “the heads
of terms of what that methodology is going to look like”.
Stewardship in regulation
Perhaps there were signals of intent from
Ofwat’s head of sustainability and natural
assets James Jenkins, when he spoke at the
Westminster Energy, Environment and
Transport (WEET) Forum last month.
He said the idea of “stewardship in water
regulation” is being explored. The crux of
this seemed to be three-fold:
❙ Prioritising a long-term perspective over
short-term fixes – for instance, considering
early interventions over end-of-pipe solutions, as encouraged in the Water White Paper; choosing actions that will be cheaper in
the long run even if they have a higher immediate cost; and creating the conditions for
sustained investment. “Stewardship keeps
the focus very clearly on the long-term and
brings that to the fore,” Jenkins pointed out.
❙ Accepting the need to make changes
along the way – Ofwat must, he said, be
able to “learn, adapt and improve” rather
than take “a set and forget approach”. This
includes by bringing “legitimacy to challenge” and encouraging stakeholders to
ask tough questions.
❙ Evolving regulatory culture so stewardship is embedded, transparency and accountability improved, and solid foundations set for a more supervisory approach.
Jenkins referred to “care, integrity and
foresight to regulatory judgement”.
Purposeful transition
Meanwhile, the sector is realising it has to
cut its coat according to its cloth. PR29 is
starting amid extensive uncertainty, and
there is more to gain from pivoting to a
position of securing strategic wins than
THE UK WATER REPORT
fighting what would be a losing battle for
a fully reformed price review.
A masterclass was given on this by Darren Rice, Anglian Water’s regulation director, at the WEET meeting. He argued:
“PR29 must be a purposeful transition. It’s
a critical bridge between the regulatory
system we currently have and the longterm regulatory framework that we need
to create.” As such, minor adjustments to
the existing model should not be tolerated; PR29 must support a deliberate transition from A to B – not least to reassure
investors, given the c£300bn investment
requirement to 2050.
“Delay and uncertainty will increase
perceived risk, raise financing costs, make
investment harder to secure, and ultimately weaken public confidence,” Rice
said. “PR29 must show the transition is
being actively managed, with clear priorities, sequencing, and governance.” He
urged: “The task is not to wait for the future framework; it is to use PR29 at pace
to start building it.”
He listed four things that PR29 needs:
❙ Clear government direction – “Firstly,
government must provide clear strategic
direction, not a list of competing objectives, but an actionable view of outcomes
that matter most, and the practical basis
for managing trade-offs between investment, affordability, performance, and environmental ambition.”
❙ A credible proposition for capital – fair
returns, predictable rules and clear allocation of risk—while keeping companies accountable and avoiding duplicate penalties.
❙ Confidence in delivery – earlier engagement between regulators and companies,
with shared understanding of regional
circumstances supported by a more supervisory approach. “The expectation is
really simple: early engagement, honest
trade-offs, clear accountability and critically, no surprises.”
❙ A strategic focus on asset health – a move
toward sustainable, long-term maintenance of essential infrastructure, based on
forward-looking assessments of needs and
risks. “PR29 won’t and can’t resolve decades
worth of asset health challenges in one period, but it can certainly establish the direction, funding principles and accountability
needed to reverse the current decline.”
Rice said there were already “green
shoots of positivity” in terms of regulators
working together in a more integrated
way, rather than priorities being “decided
PR29: A
CRITICAL
BRIDGE
The next price control
must support a purposeful
transition from the existing
regulatory regime to a
reformed framework, not
tinker at the edges.
in one room and then priced up in another”. Real credibility would come from
establishing clear priorities and openly
addressing trade-offs. “It won’t be easy because there are no obvious choices…we’re
all familiar with the body of legislation
that drive these decisions. However, there
is interpretation and guidance that goes
around those statutes. So it’s about where
those grown-up conversations with a no
surprises approach can take place. I think
doing that in plain sight, transparently,
will help with the legitimacy of all this.”
Control jeopardy
There is an elephant in the room: what the
Government’s stated desire for more public
control of water will mean in practice – including what the legislation looks like, how
companies are valued and how shareholders are compensated for any losses. Peter
O’Flaherty, asset management managing
director at investor Equitix, told the WEET:
“All of these businesses borrow very long
term, and investors generally invest for the
long term in infrastructure. If you bring in
more uncertainty, ultimately the customers
will end up paying because the capital will
become more expensive. It will be more
uncertain. You will have a shallower pool
of interested parties. I do think that’s a very
difficult decision for investors, to continue
having that hanging over an investment
where suddenly they may lose control.” TWR
The task is not to wait for
the future framework; it is
to use PR29 at pace to start
building it.
November 2026
9