TWR Nov 2026_ebook - Flipbook - Page 7
LEGITIMACY|TWR EXPERT FORUM
of the many moving parts in
play, as epitomised by this
contribution: “Maybe all going
well by 2040... But it could be
broken beyond full repair, just
like the banks are still struggling with trust post 2007,
which is almost 20 years ago.”
For some, the prospect
looks very bleak, represented
by comments such as “Never,
until politicians and the media change their tune,” “Not
anytime soon” and “Not
unless there are significant
changes in how the water industry is operated, and there
is an open conversation with
the public about water.”
Others had a glimmer of
hope for the longer-term – one
said “at least one decade, possibly two” – hinging on investment delivery and a return
to economic growth. Some
looked to other sectors for
inspiration: “Before the Post
Office scandal and the water
sector coming to the media’s
attention, the reputation of energy supply was heavily eroded
– this has now passed. I don’t
expect public trust to return
quickly - maybe in the next
generation if we focus on all of
the activities needed to rebuild
trust.”
A good number, however,
expected positive results in
AMP9 “assuming AMP8 is
properly delivered”. Estimates
here were varied, from c2035,
to mid AMP, and at the most
optimistic, at the beginning:
“I would put it at around
2031, the end of AMP8, with
a realistic window of 2030
to 2033…If bills keep rising while outcomes lag, trust
could keep falling until about
2028 before any turn.”
Some offered more nuanced positions, challenging
the blanket premise of the
question – for instance to
note that drinking water is
already first-class and trusted,
and to highlight that we may
be seeking a return to someTHE UK WATER REPORT
thing that was never really
there: “I don’t think it’s ever
been hugely positive. Speak
to those who remember life
before privatisation and water authorities weren’t hugely
loved. Regarded as under
invested-in and less than
competent quite widely. The
national picture may only
ever be neutral at best, but
the local picture can recover
better off the back of good
service and demonstration of
good practice and innovation
through high quality transparency and comms.”
Perilous consequences
There was, though, considerable agreement about the
doom loop that will result
from further prolonged depressed trust in the water
industry. Key themes here
were: difficulty/higher cost
attracting investors, which
ultimately feeds through
into higher bills; problems
attracting and retaining talent; a poorer experience for
those who are working in the
sector; more punitive policy
and regulation; supply chain
exits; customers declining to
cooperate including through
paying bills and saving water;
more sub-optimal quick-fix
solutions; and ownership reform.
One Forum member summarised: “Prolonged low trust
in the water industry would
have consequences well beyond customer sentiment. It
would affect regulation, investment, workforce, public
policy and the sector’s social
licence to operate. The effects
compound over time, so the
cost of waiting grows.”
Others emphasised that the
consequences have personal
impact, beyond the corporate/
sectoral. One shared: “Stress
and continuous negative impacts on people who work in
the industry. This is really not
nice at present — violence be-
WHAT COULD OTHERS DO?
Government
❙ “Sort out the regulatory reform. Until
that happens the narrative is firmly
that the issue hasn’t been resolved.”
❙ “Government need to decide on
the ownership and governance of
the sector. A destination for water is
desperately needed at a national
and regional level, so that everyone
from water customers, companies
and NGOs know what to expect. This
needs to be grounded in the reality
that our climate is changing.”
❙ “It could be helpful to split the sector
reforms into no regrets reforms that
can be taken forward now, giving the
sector and public at least some short
term certainty, with an agreed timeline for the areas to be reviewed.”
❙ “Ministers should set a clear, longterm framework for bills and investment, so that households and companies know the rules. Support schemes
for vulnerable customers should be
funded nationally rather than left to
individual companies.”
❙ “Government needs to support water
companies around strategic messaging. Whilst govt said in its White Paper
that it would help explain trade-offs
to the public, it hasn’t and has been
far from supportive around drought
messaging.”
Regulators
❙ “Government and regulators both
need to begin celebrating at least
ing threatened against CEOs,
violence actually being felt by
workforce trying to do their
best day and night for customers and the environment.
Investor confidence falling
and downgrading of the sector by rating agencies causing
the costs to rise further (a one
notch downgrade on the industry would put average bills
up by c.£40).”
In summary, the Forum
wasn’t quite at the point of
giving up. One championed:
“We must avoid the doom
loop. The sector has huge po-
some of the good things some of
the companies are doing some of
the time. Environmental regulators
should be taking some ownership of
the standards that they are asking
companies to achieve and recognising that these will have an impact on
bills. Not pretending that it's free/it is
not their job. Much of the media narrative is factually incorrect - regulators
should be addressing the inaccuracies and correcting them, not letting
ambiguity fester because it would be
more embarrassing for them if they
corrected things.”
❙ “Avoid one size fits all and engage in
local and regional consensus building
exercises.”
❙ “The EA need to stop telling customers
what they want to hear, such as storm
overflows being a problem, and be
honest about where the industry really
is failing customers and the environment.”
Media
❙ “It would be nice if the media reported the facts in context. But saying
that won’t make it happen.”
All
❙ “It is essential that the stakeholder
and political rhetoric moves on from
company bashing into solutions mode
- articulating that this will take time.”
❙ “Let go of the past. It doesn’t help us
deliver together in the future.”
tential - we can Make Water
Great Again!”
But the sense of all this
wearing very thin was very
much present. One commented: “As Mark Carney
said, trust arrives on foot,
and leaves in a Ferrari. So it
will be a long haul. The really tiresome thing is that in
the meantime the sector will
have to put up with politicians
preaching to the sector about
the importance of trust. And
this from a profession - politicians - that is trusted less than
estate agents!” TWR
We must avoid the doom loop. The
sector has huge potential - we can
Make Water Great Again!
November 2026
7