TWR Nov 2026_ebook - Flipbook - Page 5
GROWTH|TWR EXPERT FORUM
THE
UK WATER
REPORT
POLICY | REGULATION | FINANCE
about their performance. Trust
is falling because people judge
companies on motives and
credibility, not just on whether
the water comes out of the tap.”
❙ “Performance has not improved and the leadership of
the sector seems to have a suicidal impulse to defy the government on executive pay. It’s
frankly delusional to think that
payments through holdcos and
dodges like ‘share allocations’
are in keeping with the spirit of
the new rules. Payment for failure really annoys the public.”
❙ And the more sympathetic
view – “Issues like exec pay,
dividends, etc are clearly impacting but these are not resolvable and almost never
reflect an accurate understanding of the investment model or
labour markets for execs.”
›Everyone – “There remains
a confusing and disconnected
narrative between government, media, customers and
the sector. The water sector is a
shared accountability where all
participants have a role to play.
Until that is consistently communicated and acted upon, I’d
expect trust to remain low, inconsistent and fragile.”
Breaking the mould?
Next we asked whether public trust varies company to
company? And if so, what
drives these differences and is
there anything to learn? Many
pointed out that people tend to
rate their own company more
favourably than the sector as a
THE UK WATER REPORT
whole. Beyond that, there were
strong differences of opinion.
Perhaps the most common
view was that there are differences in practice, but this gets
lost in the noise. For instance:
“[Trust varies] massively. But
ultimately we are all tarred with
the same brush. The lesson to
learn there is that when it comes
to legitimacy, we are only as
strong as our weakest link.”
Some, however, thought trust
varied substantially and markedly. Comments included:
❙ “Public trust varies widely
between water companies, and
the spread is larger than the
national average suggests. In
the latest CCW Water Matters
survey, Northumbrian Water
scored 7.02 out of 10, while
Thames Water scored 4.74.
Thirteen companies saw their
scores fall during the year, and
the England and Wales average
dropped from 6.28 to 6.07. Earlier data showed Portsmouth
Water and Wessex Water bucking the downward trend, so
movement is possible.”
❙ “Scotland’s water trust is
higher mainly because Scottish Water is a public body, not
a shareholder-owned company, so there is no profit motive
for the public to distrust. Bills
are lower than in England, and
investment is funded through
public borrowing rather than
dividend payouts. Which?
found that two thirds of Scottish consumers trust Scottish
Water.”
❙ “To generalise, I get the impression that smaller water
only companies who perform
well are better trusted that
WaSC generally.”
On the flip side, others felt the
lack of trust to be pervasive. One
contributor offered: “Lack of
trust is endemic across the sector, worse where there have been
water supply issues or locally
significant pollution incidents.
The reputation of all companies
is poor even where water quality
and environmental condition are
good.” Another: “What is really
going on is that the media makes
money by publicising stories that
enrage their readership. Outrage
is easily provoked by describing
harm to the environment.”
Finally, one participant
highlighted interesting recent
movement in this space, with
Welsh Water and some English companies with strongly
regional identities slipping
back from relatively higher
trust score positions.
The forward trajectory
Next we asked the Expert Forum what trajectory it envisages for public trust over the next
few years. Chart 2 shows little
optimism; 79% said it will either stay the same or get worse.
Most of the rest were unsure,
with only a small minority expecting improvement.
The unsure camp made the
valid point that this is hard to
call because it depends on a lot
of variables, stretching from
what the weather has in store to
what happens with ‘public control’ and the progress of reform.
On the latter, one observed: “I
have lost trust in the Environment Agency to particular to
do anything different. The same
people are still making the same
decisions. Ofwat, Defra, and
the government are different,
and are making positive steps.
The key point will be if they can
make the EA change their tune.”
But the overwhelming view
was deeply gloomy on prospects for trust. Comments included:
❙ “Public trust in water companies is likely to deteriorate further over the next few years, because the main drivers of distrust
are structural and are still getting
worse. Bills are the clearest example. Only 44% of household customers believe their charges are
fair, a third successive fall, and
only 63% say their bill is affordable, down 11 points. Bills are
also the main reason customers
contact their supplier, so affordable pressure feeds directly into
daily frustration.”
❙ “Unless the Government
and senior politicians start
changing their narrative,
whatever we do won’t help
with trust from here.”
❙ “Performance and pay.
AMP8 delivery is also key –
some companies will simply
The leadership of the sector seems
to have a suicidal impulse to defy
the government on executive pay
November 2026
5