TWR Nov 2026_ebook - Flipbook - Page 44
THE
UK WATER
REPORT The UK Water
Report Expert
Forum
POLICY | REGULATION | FINANCE
Regular exclusive research from The UK Water Report
& Accent into the thoughts of industry leaders on the
sector’s key issues. Recent topics include:
❙ The water reform agenda and integrated regulation
❙ AMP8 expectations and experience
❙ Enabling growth
❙ Working in water at a time of low trust
TWR EXPE RT
FORU M|P OLIC
Y
THE
|TW R EXP
WATER
ERT FOR UM
REPORT
EXPER T FORU
M
UK WATER
THE
TWR EXP ERT
FOR UM| POL
ICY
THE
WATER
T
EPOR
R
RUM
EXPERT FO
“A
100%
THE
WATER
W
Integrated
regulation…
reduces duplication,
speeds approvals and
focuses outcomes.
4
November 2025
THE UK WATER REPORT
THE UK WATER REPORT
Equal partners?
First, we asked: should the regulatory functions (economic,
environmental and drinking
The big question
this Governmentfor
whether to is
seeing the water continue
stry
as public enemy indu
num
one, or to change ber
narrative into some the
thing
more positive.
THE
WATER
REPORT
❙ Size and complexity slowing
decision-making.
❙ Less transparency and
blurred accountability.
❙ More centralisation – “One
size does not fit all – regulator
must take a regional approach
to water management plans
rather than force everything
into a national model”; “A less
specialised body will be less
able to deal with the nuances
of the industry;” “Danger everything gets dumbed down.”
❙ Increased regulatory burden,
micromanagement, intrusive
regulation
❙ New silos – “By integrating
in one way, silos are created
elsewhere. For example a water only regulator may not take
account of emissions to air or
land… [and] how will water
be allocated if an integrated
regulator is just for the water
industry? Agriculture, industry and the environment are
also users of water.”
❙ Speed of transition – “Too
fast and there is a danger that
things are missed; too slow
and the sector will lose momentum.”
However, on the whole the
Forum indicated risks could
be managed, if implementation is effective, long term
strategic objectives clear, and
simplicity championed.
So what might that look
like?
ION | FINANCE
There will need
be balance betw to
een
private ownershi
public accounta p and
–
and managingbility
of the
accompanying
narrative will be
key.
UK WATER
REPORT
HIT
SINGLE
REPORT
POLICY | REGULAT
the decade. One
remarked
“most of it” would
views are complete
in
With Independ
d. The fol- “whethe
unchanged. Some fact be
sector
lowing is a rough
r there is a broaden
reasons
g changes end
grouping of
- private ownersh
Water Commissient firmly inistheenvisagin
given here were:
ing of water company
of the decade,
the answers.
ip and public
evolution raththe points ❙
remits accounta
“Its too big of
were made that
or a narrowing”.
bility – and
recommendat on er than revolutionaryarycamp.
a beast to
review after
Many sought
manmake significant
aging of
review has recomm
something akin
ions And while improvements
❙ Regulatory
changes.”
reform – This
to, as one narrative the accompanying
ended it, ❙ “The
are and there
imminent, how expected to flow
said, “recognition
amount of investme
was by far the most
is some urgency
from
that water “review will be key;” and
popular an- compani
nt
the
expectant is
liffe recommendations Cun- a shake-up. For example for at risk in the sector is too
swer. Under this
of ownership
es,
farmers/landhigh
the
umbrella
: “I to introduc
and
be move to partial – maythink the sector
rum members expected , Fo- owners, highways,
e major changes.
of substantial sector well as those from other re-as change
will have to
listings.”
local au- Other
”
a wide thorities
❙ “There have
change
range of developm
comments relevant
significantly. The
all have a key part
views (Corry,
been water
ents, from play
pace distribut
to here were
Na- at the start
in the next five
ion
the
in
that
extreme
water
compani
of AMP8 does
policy changes
tional Audit Office,
sector improve
(“Abolish Ofwat”)
es for
years?
not over 400
- resulting from
give confidence
ments”. There was
and the personal
years, and sewerParliamentary
the sector rethat the proalso expec- views
(“A change in
inquiage companies
tation of “increase
must ensure the
Ofwat’s managem
for 170 years,
ries), these changes grammes will be delivered
aunchd regional is
sector
ent team”),
. and not much
investable and
To have a chance
system planning
to better execution
has changed
are not expected
attractive.
ing his
to spend the
– with more
of the ex- role
to sums needed
over that timescal
isting mandate
for local decision
is going to need
e. Rain will
yield a slam dunk
C a l l for
. This included
❙ A water “mission
still fall from the
a very different
and accountability” making ❙ Asset health –
expectations of
on trust.
sky and flow
” – There
Evidence
approach. OfThis needs is
simplification
as
some hope the
downhill due
wat’s current
“improved managem well as to be better understo
(of functions
back in February
to gravity. The
reviews will
man-marking,
od and draw
and account,
core water and
a line in the sand
while noble in
the water life cycle”. ent of guided. One member
ability)
Indep endent
and
Slow
wastewa
seeking
a good sort out
pace
said: “A enable
and
ter
to en- treatmen
Water
base mainten
stakeholders to
(reorganisation
t process science
Commission
ance amnesty
As chart 1 shows, sure programmes/outcomes
rally
of responsibilichair Sir Jon
has
around a higher
been broadly
is
are delivered,
needed
❙
Strategic
a bigger proporti
ties,
Cunliffe said
to
better
purpose, acrealign existing
the same for
direction – some
is having the
alignment between
he had been
on
companied by
over 100 years.
asset condition
thoughts were:
thought the sector (27%) opposite effect as
regulators).
“asked frequent
”
“a narrative
and provide
“More strategic
it is placly over the
will
reset”.
be
a
Areas
better
ing
One
direction
largely the same
additional obligatio
specifically expectcontributor comstarting point
Some specific
last few months
for en- mented:
as today by
changes to includin from Government, hanceme
ns / ed to be
what out- 2030,
requirements
“The big question
the regulatory
left unchanged
nt costs.”
come the Commis
than thought it
g the affordabi
on the water
for
regime were
inwill have
lity
sion is changed
this Governm
cluded: drinking
envelope” and
also cited, includin
seeking and whether
ent is whether
substantially (18%). companies, slowing scheme
water quala “cost benefit
g
we will 55%
to continue seeing
ity regulation;
❙ Funding
progress.”
powered Outcom “lower- analysis requirement
be recommending
believed it will
environmental
environm
the
waental
for
e Deliv- ture
evolution- changed
fu- improvements
have
ter industry as
legislation; basic
At the other
ery Incentiv
statutory requirem
ary or revolutio
public enemy
a little.
– while the
company
end of the
es;” “remove
nary change”.
ents”.
number one,
activities (operatio
sector’s basic
spectrum were
Price Control
To qualify this,
His position was
or to change
funding model
those who exns, asset
Delivera
a number of
that the outthe narrative into
planning and
is expected to
pected the sector
participants made
“changes to economi bles;” ❙ Clarity on ownersh
come needed is
project delivsomething
remain intact,
to remain ery);
ip – De- there
the point largely
a trusted and
c regula- spite
more positive.”
the fundamental
that on-paper
was recognition
tion to promote
sustainable industry
as it is by the
nationalisation
changes may
tenets
longer
end of of the
that
being environm
, and that be
funding model
thinking and resilienc term formally off the table
made
ental outcomes
the Commission
(primay ❙ Public
at the
would rec- legislatio by 2030 (such as via
e;” “Of- Cunliffe
vate ownership,
transparency –
wat should be
ommend “whateve
Review, the Forum require some funding innovan), but real change
with invesCHART 1: HOW
Progfocussed on
r we think will
ress has been
tors paying upfront
tion, due to their
did not anticipat
ensuring the funds
is necessary, in
made here, but
take longer to
SUBSTANTIALL
high cost and
costs and
e
line with our
current
achieve.
are
Y
there
procustomers repaying
to catchment-based
is anticipation
arrangem
For instance, one
vided to achieve
terms of referenc
WILL THE WATER
of more.
this over
delivery. One
said: “2030
the agreed touched. ents will be left un- One
e, to achieve
time); and “the
participant shared:
suggested: “A Water
is not a distant
outcomes rather
SECTOR HAVE
that outcome”.
Among
core
the
model
“I
than
sugges- collected
Tax
horizon.
lowest tions
of RCV based
CHANGED BY BEEN
Changes will
cost;” and “a
with bills, for spend- would like to see a central
of what we might
Judging by response
regulation and
take time to
repudiation of
2030? regular
see ing by others
independent platform
were: “Strengt
price reviews).
the fake assessme
latest Expert Forum s to our agree and then
in other sectors”
hen control of
set up
implement.
|TWR EXPERT FORUM
nts of busisurvey, the By
where stakehol
and also a “cost
water company
ness plans/the fake
2040 I would
ders (includof abstracted
ownership water
expect subdistinction models
Prospective
stantial change
imposed
between
changes
and behaviou
that reflects
enhancement
for the
Substantially
rs;” the environm
Largely the
and “launch
To get some visibility
Another observed sector.”
base expenditure.
18%
further enquiry
ental and social
same
of where
”
: “These
into
change
impacts
water company
27%
things will take
is expected, we FORUM| POLICY
of surface and ground
ownership water
time to flow
EXPERTasked
TWR
respond
models includin
through. Culture
abstraction, so
ents to identify
❙ Remit revisitat
g
compare-nation
the
change is
ion
THE
five most importan
required in our
Changed
– the Forum
alisatio n;” “tighter nies develop better plans
t alterainstitutio
GROWTH|TWR
EXPERT
FORUM
exto
a little
ns.”
tions they expect
abstract water
pects change
Among those
controls on
55%
frompolicies
to see made
the bestby
on
expecting
share- environm
and
issues
by the Governm
significant change
remit, althoug
on key industry
ent source rather
ent to the waholder returns;”
h
help us get fast feedback
June 2025
by the
Please
ter sector when
is simple, easy and
process
it remained
The the
local environm
Forum.than
it implements
Expert will
open
ental
Water Report“there
its decisions after
source.” Othersonce every
few
| FINANCE
to question, as joining our The
POLICY | REGULATION
a survey suggested new
all the reone
will be
to emailed
. You need
be charges for
anonymous
par ticipan t
send
develope
online.
rs Accent
putcompletely
b a n c e to
alongit,
THE UK WATER
THE
sidecomplete
partnera lAccent,
mandating water
REPORT
months by our research
efficien-issue.
b e t w e e n we
in the following
THE UK WATER
report
cy in
new builds.
data which
REPORT
us aggregate, anonymised
are working at a
new members, so if you
We are actively seeking
company or at another
in the sector, within a
reasonably senior level
o.uk to
June
aterreport.c
POLICY | REGULATION | FINANCE
2025
5
, please email karma@thew
stakeholder organisation
The lows
to our existing members.
Among the recommendalimwhich recomjoin. Thank you very much
❙ “I’m disappointed by the
topics We also asked
ly and professionally in always
the tions on more specific
members diseasy to agree
ited focus on strengthening
firm Forum sup- mendations
direc- ficult to read but
indidelivering in the best interests
encouraging that attracted
“Much of it reflects existing
the
agreed with. In another
envi- supply chain and
with;” “On balance reflects
port were:
the
of their customers, the
tion of travel. It’s no less important
cation of the strength of
to see. Not
greater openness to innovation.
to act changes we need
ronment, and their investors,
drivwork, multiple
for that, with the potential
”
These areas are critical for
and resilience Commission’s
100% – but mostly support.
and in managing the trade-offs
reduc- ›Asset health
said there was
resilience,
as a catalyst for change.” Others,
respondents
especially
long-term
water quality) have an equal
ing
be
Some highlighted
standards
between them, we wouldn’t
to say here.
however, saw limitations:
had
voice in strategic decisioning costs, and ensuring competthe most powerful nothing
give that the Commission
where we are. The government
receive only ❙ “By far
❙ “There is little here to
sysMany of those who did dismaking within an integrated
re- itiveness, yet they
grasped the big picture on
recommendations are around
must also bear some of the
confidence that economic
attention. The review
agree with an element stated
regulator? As chart 2 shows,
by failing to expose modest
The temic issues:
establishment of resilience
the
change.
sponsibility
specific.
seta
in
will
quite
further
regulation
two-thirds said yes, with the
in- could have gone
overdue.” something
IWC gets it – a broken
Cunliffe has put forward
and set out the trade-offs
en- standards - long long
ons for environ- ❙ “The
Some examples are:
remainder split between disting out practical steps to
will the recommendati
water cycle that needs a differ“How
volved in regulation.”
adopt
mental regulation are ambigu❙ The appeals regime –
robust reform plan, but
agreeing and being unsure.
able new market entrants,
Others still felt the report
ge? ous. The report focuses more ent approach.” finally that the
and ›Finance and governance
write a report which so
One respondent called this
had emerging technologies,
of volatility in can you
sector rise to the challen
the ❙ “Recognition
ecowas broadly positive but
procure- ❙ “The removal
on the regulators than
obviously recognises that the
regulation
“the million dollar question”.
miss- create a more dynamic
is quite revolutionary. It’s
no system of economic
financing.”
key elements missing or
erfect, no, but pretty Ofwat
water industry, and makes
is not
nomic regulator has completely
Most thought equal balment environment.”
is totally broken…Ofwat
quite clear what will replace
❙ “Regulators will gain powers
ing the mark. Two examples
remove the
solid. That is The not
recommendations that would
it was
ance was key, as this comment
that lost its way and then
being abolished because
“Single integrated regulator,
to block ownership changes
are (and more gaps are identithat they have
Water Report Ex- it;”
enable the delivery of improveaccountability
only
PR
highs
companies
epitomises: “It will be key to try is in now.” Another argued:
with
The
by
interest.”
dissatisfaction
weak/captured
”
fied in the section below):
asked undermine public
Illogical.”
pert Forum’s overall complete
ments from other sectors.
its
have parity between regula- “The raison d’etre for existence
To probe further, we
oversight via the CMA?
it is being abolished because
process and all of building blocks
❙ “The most disappointing
rec- ❙ “Stricter financial
need for a new framework
❙ “Changing the regulator
assessment of the recommentors – to create a functioning, of water companies is to proForum members which
companies and ❙ The
regulatory regime is breaking
(outcomes, totex, WACC, QAA)
water
area for me was how superthey most of the water
does not guarantee a change
comdations from Sir Jon Cunliffe
to drive the adoption of
and healthy, tension.” Another vide a service: drinking water
of ‘asset ommendations
total rethink.”
the entire industry/no
measures to enforce
implies
coverage
many
the
if
tougher
how
ficial
re“[Recom–
especially
reforming
Multiple
of approach
and team on
said: “Equal weighting will be for public health and environfor fund- reuse infrastructure
this firmly support.
can live with it. Regional
Those selecting evolution
far
health’ was, conflating
they improvements made
people are ab- pany
water is planned, managed
mendation] 40 doesn’t go
needed to fully understand mental protection. Money/
spondents indicated that
parts of of the same
sensible/bench”
the
less highlighted that core
regulator. planning is
with overall asset manage(first seven), ing received.
and regulated. What is far
enough as it does not meet
will sorbed into the new
too far.”
the challenges and balance the finances/economic regulation
once endorse the core
the existing framework
much marking has gone
ment (a term that did not
direction
to
The sector clearly needs
certain is what will happen
first principle of good rainwater
are only a facilitator for these
best outcome.”
refer- covering strategic
In what is true credit
narrative
on remain, albeit in rationalised/ more investment, but the govfeature other than in
was also ›The public
- which states that
now. Opinion is divided
feels
As indicated in some of the primary purposes.”
L). and planning. There
recommendation management
the Commission, a number
improved/clearer form: “It
locally
ence to licence condition
for the rec- ❙ “The best
ernment has already spoken
how holistically government
Notable though is that not
earlier comments, some bealso said they
stop rain should be captured
be a widespread praise
like a shuffle of the decks rather
which of participants
is for the government to
To some degree this may
where possible. This
“The
will adopt the recommenda” one against bill increases
lieved economic functions all agreed with that outlook.
ommendations on regulatory
about the and reused
felt listened to – such as:
than a new set of cards,
reflection not just of Cunliffe’s
at property
com- negative briefings
rain
many
very helpful. There is a
the
valuing
to
isn’t
Among
able
tions, and how enthusiasticalmeans
was
“They
would try to dominate and One said: “While it would be
reform.
team
a said. Another observed:
water industry.”
get a differ- Commission
harvestteam’s expertise but the nature
ly the sector will get behind
baby risk that we just
would need to be reined in. equitable if all were equal, the
sector’s issues
ments were support for: “Single
huge level through rainwater
are not throwing out the
❙ “Recognition that a
complex understand the
of those responding, which
Cunliffe Renew era of public service.
third ent flavour of overly
One said: “Without this [equal- practicalities are economic
regulator and rationalisation
and put forward
been ing, whereas the
(privatised model with
effects and their causes
was largely from a regulatory
with amount has actually
view does not go this far.”
the regulation with similar
ity], funding and direction regulation should take priorof legislation - dealing
remedies. It was quite
party investment) with
achieved in improving sewage
and financial background.”
of clear direc- logical
Revolution or evolution?
goes / is directed by whoever ity, public health next and then
too many layers of regulations
model).” including a lack
impressive. There was proper
”
discharges since privatisation;
Fo- bathwater (regulatory
– “For
tion and a lack of funding.
Just over half the Expert
is loudest. Historically this has environmental regulation.”
that create overlaps, underbest ❙ Capital maintenance
engagement with stakeholders
Some participants stressed that
the UK has the some of
final
that the
CHART 2 – HOW
rerum (54%) viewed the
thing:
More widely, some responbeen the economic regulator,
laps and inconsistencies across
in the me, the proposition
across the sector and it was
evolution was a positive
to drinking water quality
PLEASED ARE
Overall sentiment
recommendations as evoluScottish approach to setting
which has almost entirely led dents put forward the view
regulators;” and “The move
ar
the
listened to.”
for
n
feel
pleased THE
to
– HowWITH
2
freshing
Chart
recommendatio
YOU
(namely,
model where the world;
We asked Forum members
tionary and 42% as revoluto the dire situation the indus- that customer preferences
negatively capital maintenance
Those who were more neuCHART 1 – ARE THE s o
RECOMMENDATIONS? a supervisory
backare with the
its government to stop
that the
tionary, suggesting perhaps ChartRECOMME
age-based) is a huge step
should guide the balance of
regulator will have improved
NDATIONS how pleased they
1 – Are the recommendation
In tral tended to indicate
briefing about the water indus- we
recommendations overall.
the Commission has struck
wards to the early 1990s
power between regulatory
capabilities and have informed
Disappointed
ons are someCHART 2: SHOULD
OVERALL MORE:
try and to start giving positive
as a ringing recommendati
pursuthan this,
in
read
4%
be
company
better
must
far
each
balance
with
what
done
one
good
As
a
have
bag.
THE REGULATORY
discussions
they thing of a mixed
messaging and support.”
endorsement 69% said
FUNCTIONS HAVE
ing meaningful but practical
developing way more nuanced
Don’t
egg - good
on its specific circumstances,
neu- put it: “It’s a curate’s
apknow 4%
Neutral
AN EQUAL VOICE?
were pleased overall, 27%
on
change (see chart 1).
risk- and value-based
rather than rely on econometin parts. Cunliffe focuses
27%
›Other
tral and just 4% disappointed
The revolutionaries cited
ric models of very dubious
Pleased
a single social
regulatory system as the arthe
metering,
Smart
the
that
totality
69%
(see chart 2).
among their reasons
robustness to set the
Evolutionary
for a statutory
chitect of the perceived failure,
Don’t know
reRevolutionary
54%
like a tariff, the need
For many, the positive judgepackage “fundamentally
17%
of allowances. This feels
devote sufficient
trans42%
to
digital
fails
and
but
the
in
ombudsman,
the
had
ment was one made
root
shapes the structure of
move back to what Ofwat
scrutiny to whether the
formation.
genround. Comments included:
sector” and is a “once in a
pre-2012.”
2025
No
the companies themis
cause
September
18%
“Really sensible recommendaethicaleration shift - if implemented”.
dif- selves. If they had acted
acts
Yes
tions, balanced and fair,
Some highlighted specific
65%
THE UK WATER REPORT
of
UK WATER REPORT
of radicalism: “Getting rid
The amount of
investment
the sector is tooat risk in
introduce majorhigh to
changes.
4
M
UK WATER
L
HT ROAD
ON THE RIG
EXPE RT FORU
THE
PACE OF CHA
NGE
REPORT
s by
and policie
industry issues
easy and
ack on key
ss is simple,
us get fast feedb
. The proce
Please help
t Expert Forum
every few
survey once
The Water Repor
emailed a
joining our
. Accent send
You will be
anonymous.
complete online
completely
Accent, to
ng issue.
ch partner
in the followi
resear
report
our
by
we
months
g at a
data which
anonymised
if you are workin
er
us aggregate,
members, so
of
any or at anoth
ly seeking new
❙ “Refinement
, within a comp
We are active
o.uk to
more modest
ce duty
in the sector
aterreport.c
For others,
senior level
are in resilien
karma@thew
greater use
reasonably
or clarifications
, please email
to be more specan help support
/ changes
organisation
members.
was a good deal of blended / pooled funding
For example:
stakeholder
cific on asset
to our existing
Again, there
ed in order.
but not a main responses.
and support
you very much
health. For the
❙ “It’s an issue,
join. Thank
of commonality the need to investment,
vel sector plans),
of regulator
g / some
nment
cies, high-le
Clarity
ted
plannin
es
ent
one.
Enviro
, resourc
catchm
Many highligh
better- jor
with emgain a
and more capacity for crossacross sectors,
delivery by
functions coupled identify Agency to
join up budgets a level play- catchment
/
ent partnerwill help
and accountability
to be
value for money
powerment
resourced catchm
and for there
ent partnerships
”
sector catchm
regulation across ships.”
cost benefit duty.
the gaps.”
In between,
ing field in
out: “Planider
I don’t think
the local level.
indicated that
fill
❙ “Cons
to help at
❙ “Personally
Another pointed
sectors. Some
ry decktheir
l groups should
year updates
risk
require ments
the regulato
need to pull
where the
in terms
the with fivee against boom and regiona
other sectors
re- moving
– ning/g rowth
can make
‘missing middle’
into account
reward sits.
mitigat
alongside water
will help. We
rt Forum says
chain, the
do not take
weight more
ing and steering
rs work and
makes the
ges at chairs
Report Expe the right track, bust effect in supply
g,
e:
system challen
er
existing regulato joined Consider what
rm of oversee le
plannin
the
instanc
long-te
source/
Wat
for
The
or tick - what
ent-sca
r, more
e to focus
to give greater
t. Still no require
relevant regulat
invest- catchm
mission is on
combined
better togethe
Consistently and
❙ “Don’t continu source dis- the momen
strategic and
y over agreed
initiatives such their objectives are.
housing to be
of
point
Cunliffe Com rs views on the con
erm with
s
up, through
ment for all new
the boards
on reducing
es;” “Long-t
up. certaint
r the answer
ngly lower
But the environ
authorities on
t.”
ment prioriti
sider whethe
and offe
r
as RAPID.
water efficien
has flagged
charges at increasi
are hampered
l groups (alongic regulawith one anothe
because it is
plans exist, but
r the regiona
s the team
ment and econom level peg- are aligned
navigation,
value for money ”
of the five-yea
certain obcontrols, ownns
raised issue
be on
side agri, energy,
to do.
if they have
by the rigidity
tory functio
length of price
sector
the easy thing
was tors should than the economy - i.e.
es Regula
solid start”
) have all been AMP cycle. A rolling review industry, environment
risks and rethere
the
measur
models
are
that
,
level,
tership
And
plans may
❙ “Recognition
rs’ ging, rather
ment jectives
- At a high
continuously
becoming accoun
a n d “e n the environ
that regulato
water environ
aligned to those.
based on 25-year to invest reps), and
the
reviewed almost
agreement
, trumping
sibility
to improve the
elements of
ed to wards
ion.”
the
couragingly
freedom
their
clarified
respon
by
perceiv
be
for
conclus
or
better
to
are
taken
able
offer
be
they
with little
es with
check where
too
functions need
ment must
up, when
outcomes whilst plan and how it interfac
elming, there
compreget forgotten
.”
farming sectors, better aligned and tidied
in long-term
But overwh
be in conflict
- lies. These
risk
Water
d
strategic spatial
transport and
confidence
ers visibility
as
The
Govern
and
sibility,
plans,
polarise
well
up
custom
m
three
ties as
growth
were more
was optimis
often – respon
hensive” sum
“There are
his offering
deof bills. Betand local authori There is a but there
flood risk man(Cunliffe,
favoured ❙
Forum’s overCunliffe and
. Removal of
y.
and predictability e planning plans, local
in Sir Jon
on how. Some
Report Expert
ment reviews and three and reward
es, highways
the water industr
ed the work
the views
the industr y
adaptiv
nts towards
consolidation.
Corry)
agement strategi
we rearrange
team. One describ review that ter use of
tail could make
riding sentime
local naacregulatory
a NAO and
risk here that
”
ring from the
ent plans and
t and make
ittees (HoL,
welcome
irs without
e: “Potentially
will also help.
more efficien
the first outpou
term investm
select Comm
in
is- as “A very
planning deckcha of those For instanc
y strategies.”
the OEP,
ly be the catalyst ❙ Balance with the short
clearer e.g.
Water Comm
sector regulaEAC), plus
for ture recover to bridge gaps
countability
Independent
Evi- will hopeful
the insingle water
improving delivery
the key issues
g
planning EFRA, are reviewing the
finally do we
its Call for
change across
– “ Focus on
governs all
than ❙ Plannin
permits. And
sion (IWC):
who all
until for real
up with other
plans.”
es tor that
we need
towards a truly
years (rather
organisations,
decisions.
which is live
“More join
water resourc
the next ten
thing. What
dustry, a move
investment
need as many
dence (CfE),
, data/IT,
the costs –
❙ “Currently
and bethat is robust,
mental same
to regulate
plans (energy
is very and
sector
evaluation of
d
EA
system
environ
this
and
sector
and
”
in
ed
Englan
50)
d
April.
resilient
both
23
supply;
planning in
l... A dedicat monitoring and is DWI
and well thought and benefits of any propose
was universal
) on water
ns (DWI being
sectors?”
uni-directiona
;” housing
r for
well managed
In fact, there
plans
who
ry their functio e of how to do tween
passive and
the price
in the process
long term
we regulato
our Forum
on
ic
by the public
and
regulato
early
from
cted
views
of
need
“Realist
ent
changes
you
of/respe
Forum
agreem
enforcement
be on lonl a good exampl
tell us what
based
cycle are
ledge and bridge
l service.”
ission had hit
process and
tly with risk
“The focus should but there that acknow
. There doesn’t compliance, and the remova
rely on its essentia
that the Comm
act review
g
will provide
re- it efficien
t requirements
p14.
Forum what
tive
head in identiand Ofwat to
term plannin
the differen
in the box on
nal delivery
any substan
We asked the
rs –
the nail on the
:
regulation)
each of ger
of operatio
seem to be
ion and shown
balance between from the different regulato t
issues as follows
like to see on
sectors to focus quirements from the current as economic regulat
should be a
fying the key
short
contras
rm it would
es
steer to other
raised isment
(25yr+) and
can be in direct
clear long-te
of outcom
regulator (parthe consistently
le long term 5yr). Everything which
the need for
ungry develop
enforcement
environmental
has
Acknowledging
TWR EXPERTwater-h
FORUM|REGULATION
need for strate- sues and areas of possib
And: “ComThe problem
to each other.
there is water
term (up to
planning; the
ticularly flood).” where all and duties.
in areas where
ed by the
quickly we can- the impacts of climate change
across secive EA and
Forum
is changing so
regulation
gic coordination interacting change identifi
been a) ineffect etch and
of the Expert
available.”
events on both
the UK might
gover- bined
ng or
red together
ission.
IWC’s
ed
overstr
foresee what
and weather
the
not
conside
cusComm
ent-bas
Ofwat
are
with
tors impacti
what
and
b)
sort
areas
Catchm
agreed
years and
relying
e availability
the need to
as a route to
tly finance does
the sector
look like in 25
, alongside
with water;
be. We resourc
and
nance was cited
ur is key.”
a is key. Curren environment growth
assessment that planning,
planning
rs’ functions
x comparachallenges might
r
tomer behavio
ation, set in
Long-term
conside
out regulato
on comple
com- the
long term
events with
better coordin
Please
help us get fast
on key industry
and policies
by
e, not
doesfeedback
A resetissuesneeds:
the price review There was a good deal of
1:100 years
. For instanc
incentives.
, environment
nation across
to improve
an
ination
mem- have
enough
yearly fre, tiveExpert
ic coordi
wider context
2011
enough
strateg
joining our
The Water
Report
The
process
is simple,
easy and ion
the need for
seems like
y in Forum
from the
Strategic coord
eForum.
r recommended: not
process; and
consider finance
issue what
t.”
r is overdu
, slicker regulat
ucture monalit
s
one membe
l
sectors
ions on the
at the momen
not conside You willreview
anyway.”a survey once
across sector
and regiona
completely
everyimprov
few ed
improved infrastr ork.
bers’ suggest
er doesanonymous.
Gray be emailed respong. Key quency yered planning –
custom
strategic coor“Catchment
not
and
for
plannin
straframew
does
ce
of
rm
need
quality
resilien
❙ Multi-la
with greater
number to complete
ment,
iate The
A Accent,
months
by our
research
partner
send
smoothly on
some of long-te
for online. Accent
governance,
resilience.
of environ
ork of appropr
- i.e. some
There were
specific ideas
were:
dination follows
ty ownership
r cost etc etc
dents offered
– “A “A framew
oversight
that themes
conside
point; as one
tegic authori
us aggregate,
anonymised
which we report in the following issue.
13
are di- data
, planning,
on priorities
comments
from the former said, cross
g and investApril 2025
r requirements
change:
has ❙ Clarity
at the nar
c priori- strategy
decision-makin
by regulato
other.” new
We are actively
seeking
members, so if you are working at a
what the IWC
set of strategi
with each
and accountability local lev- Forum membeand long-term
es, supported
so clearer
rectly at odds
ment prioriti
g
government
l and
essentially done
g group that reasonably senior level in the sector, within a company or at another
sector plannin
issued from
tional, regiona
lly
what ties
to be “mutua
to be a new
a regional plannin
a more priorifar is to replay
planning need
Ofwat, with
els. There needs
stakeholder organisation, please email karma@thewaterreport.co.uk to
the water
– and, to
REPORT
ive”.
l strategy for
it has heard
list.”
THE UK WATER
, poli- support
s plans nationa
mem- tised
join. Thank you very much to our existing members.
T
ment (targets
term busines
REPOR
as one Forum
environ
Longer
❙
s plans
of the
THE UK WATER
r-term busines
ber said, “Most
(e.g. – “Longe
❙ Ending the overlap / gaps be- ❙ “Integrated regulation…re- forthcoming change, as this
these imperatives – rather
topics of detail
tween regulators, and instead duces duplication, speeds ap- comment encapsulates: “This
than operate as a perverse
enabling intelligence shar- provals and focuses outcomes. is a real opportunity to make
influence. Government will
2025
12 April
ing and integrated solutions Companies gain certainty to a real step change that could
need to be very clear about
to address several challenges invest, innovate and collaborate have massive benefit for the
priorities and outcomes.”
through one action or invest- across catchments. Customers whole country. I sincerely
❙ “Loss of genuine world-class
see better service, fairer bills hope the opportunity is not
ment.
expertise (especially impor❙ Providing better clarity for and transparency. Environment wasted through political detant with DWI) in favour of
The sector strongly all, including on strategic di- benefits from holistic planning, lays and uncertainty/watering
more generalist approach –
down
of
the
Independent
Wadata
sharing,
risk-based
overrection,
leading
to
less
conflict.
this
has happened in the EA
supports the prospect
ter Commission recommen❙ Offering better value, includ- sight and climate resilience.”
with the reduction in the sciof one, joined-up water ing through ending duplica- ❙ “There is an opportunity to dations. The volatility, uncerentific programme leading to
loss of experts.”
regulator – but views tion and better utilising re- streamline the duties of the tainty and challenges we face
regulator – making it clear are not going away and real
❙ “Risk that drinking water
are mixed on how best ❙sources.
Aligning priorities to over- what is essential, and what is change across the industry
quality issues are lost in the
is essential if we are to meet
new regulator.”
to make it work. come the current siloed ap- merely nice to have.”
proach and drive better out- ❙ “I have long supported the these challenges and change
❙ “Must retain investor confidence for the privatised model
ater
sector comes. This includes enabling integration of the EA and Of- the perception and perforto work - a regulator not foopinion,
as informed trade-offs to be wat (not so sure about DWI) mance of the industry.”
as recent history has shown
cused on the City-view could
articulated by made.
lead to a flight of capital.”
those on our ❙ Agreeing a glide path be- that political pressure to not Mitigating risk
Many were concerned that
Expert Forum, is enthusi- tween short and long term increase bills has resulted in All that said, the Forum was
under-investment in the sec- cognisant of the many risks
change could prove superficial
astically behind the idea of objectives.
if behaviours don’t also shift:
setting up a single regula- ❙ Enabling a consistent strate- tor. By bringing them together, involved in bringing regulaa national water policy that is tors together under one ban❙ “The main risk is that curtor in England and in Wales, gic narrative.
rent mindset / practices
wrapping in drinking water, ❙ Supporting regional (cross- cognisant of the environment ner. A key concern was getting
continue, if the new regulaenvironmental and economic sector) and catchment plan- as well as bill payers would the right balance between the
be an improvement. We need composite interests – environtor doesn’t have the right
functions. As chart 1 shows, ning.
Just a few of the many en- to develop a medium-to-long ment, finance and customer.
forward-looking culture and
88% of respondents to our
becomes an extension of the
latest sentiment-seeking sur- thusiastic comments we re- term vision in a world of cli- Comments included:
mate change – i.e. more floods ❙ “Risk that the board discuscurrent system.”
vey supported the idea of in- ceived were:
and droughts – and invest in sions/decisions become too
❙ “Creating the best of all regutegrated regulation overall.
increasing the resilience of the focussed on one or more of
lators rather than a mediocre
CHART 1: DO YOU
SUPPORT THE IDEA
asset base. A joined up regula- these agendas.”
mishmash from what went beOpportunities
OF INTEGRATED
tor could look on the environ- ❙ “The risk is that economic
fore. Avoiding this will require
The opportunities are numerREGULATION?
regulation will consider itself
ment as a client.”
a clear focus, senior sponsorous, the Forum said. Factors
There was some wider reti- to be the senior partner. The
ship and engagement with all
listed included:
Don’t know
cence about the DWI being water companies’ main purstakeholders.”
No 6%
6%
wrapped in. One member pose is firstly to protect public
❙ “This is the opportunity of
urged: “Do not include DWI health through the provision
a generation. We can’t let that
in the new regulator – it is too of clean drinking water and
slip through our grasp by just
important and doing a great effective sanitation, and sechaving the same old regulaYes
job to be compromised by a ondly to protect and improve
88%
tion with a pretty new ribbon
the environment. Economics
large new regulator.”
around it.”
But on the whole, the Fo- should support the behaviours
Other risks identified inrum was excited about the and investment to deliver
cluded:
GRO WTH |TWR
Please help us
get fast feedba
ck on key industry
joining our The
issues and policies
Water Report
Expert Forum.
by
completely anonym
The process is
simple, easy and
ous. You will be
emailed a survey
months by our
research partner
once every few
Accent, to comple
us aggregate,
te online. Accent
anonymised
data which we
send
We are actively
report in the followin
seeking new
g issue.
members, so
reasonably senior
if you are working
level in the sector,
at a
within a compa
stakeholder organis
ny or at anothe
ation, please
r
email karma@
join. Thank you
thewaterreport.
very much to
co.uk to
our existing membe
rs.
PORT
RE
EXPERT FORUM
Do not include
DWI in the new
regulator – it is
too important and
doing a great job to be
compromised by a
large new regulator.
The main risk is that
current mindset /
practices continue, if the
new regulator doesn't
have the right forwardlooking culture and
becomes an extension of
the current system.
November 2025
UK WATER
REPORT
ONWARDS AND
UPWARDS?
P
It’s a curate’s egg good in parts.
THE
4
September 2025
5
Contact karma@thewaterreport.co.uk to suggest
Forum topics or to enquire about joining.
5