TWR Nov 2026_ebook - Flipbook - Page 41
WATER RESOURCES|INDUSTRY COMMENT
INDUSTRY COMMENT
SECOND
USE FIRST
Chris Payne
makes the case
for industrial
reuse before
new supply.
By mid October, national
reservoir storage was at 54% of
capacity, around 21% below the
long-term average. Parts of four
areas were in severe drought
and ten areas in drought. There
were 449 restrictions on abstraction licences, and another 1,383
licence holders had cut abstraction by half voluntarily.
For an industrial site, that makes
one thing plain. The most secure
supply on the premises is the water
that’s already come through the
gate. It needs no licence and no
drought permit. The technology to
use it twice has existed for years.
What’s thin is the reason to buy it.
Easy savings have gone
Most sites have done the first round
of leaks, nozzles, clean-in-place
(CIP) timing and operator habits.
On the sites we see, that first pass
can take up to half off consumption. Breweries that ran above four
litres of water for every litre of beer
now run below three. That work
takes months.
What’s left is process, and
process takes years. It needs a
change in thinking, changes to
plant, a capital budget and a
payback case. The time, the
skills and the people needed
all multiply. And the capital has
to fight production for its return,
which production usually wins. So
the water infrastructure falls into
disrepair until something fails. The
volumes left are smaller than that
first 50%, and the returns on them
are higher.
THE UK WATER REPORT
Nobody owns the water
between stages
Water a site has paid for once
leaves it from a handful of places:
softener regeneration backwash
and rinse, reverse osmosis reject,
cooling tower blowdown, filter
backwash, and CIP rinse. All of
them can be treated and reused,
and all are reused somewhere.
Almost nowhere are all of them
looked at together.
The reason is ownership. Water
is in every process, so it belongs to
no single one. Utilities management
is often a firefighting job, keeping
ageing equipment producing what
the site needs today. Each department is focused on its own objectives. The water leaving a stage is
the next department’s problem,
and the next department is measuring something else.
So sites improve the efficiency
of one equipment area and never
ask where the water leaving that
stage could go. A beverage producer cuts its water ratio across the
brewhouse and the packaging hall,
then stops at the point where the
water reaches the effluent plant.
Membrane filtration at that point
can return a high volume of water
to the site. The stage that would use
it is on the other side of an organisation chart.
The stream most often missed
is CIP. Every equipment industry
cleans in place, usually with a
caustic wash, and almost none of it
is recycled.
Second use in Spalding
Pilgrim’s Europe at Spalding is the
illustration we use because of how
little it took. Softener regeneration
backwash and fast rinse, about 40
cubic metres a day of low-salinity
water, had gone straight to drain.
Across the yard, livestock lorries
were being washed down with
mains water. The backwash was
already clean enough for the job.
All it needed was a route.
The route was a dual-leg drain
line and two air-actuated valves on
the site’s existing control loop, built
with a local fabricator. No new
treatment plant and no operator
to run it. Between commissioning
in May 2022 and June 2025, the
site saved over 26m litres of mains
water and kept the same volume
out of the trade effluent meter.
That’s where the business case for
most second uses sits: the saving
lands twice, and the capital is a
fraction of what a new treatment
stage would cost.
The other thing Spalding shows is
that the question and the answer sit
with different people. The question
needs someone who sees both
ends of the site. The answer needs
someone who knows the water.
Is there a site where reuse isn’t the
answer? From a technical standpoint, almost never. Every stream
can be put to some use, right up
to minimal or zero liquid discharge,
where there’s nothing left to send
anywhere. The limits are the ones
this piece has been about: whether
anyone owns the stream, whether
the capital case beats production’s, and whether the receiving
use will take the water as it comes.
The attention
is on rain. The
water leaving a
Rain, and policy attention
process stage,
in the wrong place
which on most
Rainwater harvesting is the route
sites is the cheaper that gets the policy attention. Harvested rainwater needs no abstracand steadier
tion licence, under an Environment
litre, is the part
Agency position statement valid
April 2029, and for a site with
nobody’s writing until
a large roof and a non-potable
policy for.
demand close by it has a place.
Chris Payne is co-founder
and director of PureTec
Separations, which
designs, builds and
maintains water and
wastewater treatment
systems for industrial sites.
Its limit is intermittency. Rain arrives
in bursts and demand doesn’t, so
storage sizing decides whether a
scheme pays.
The Independent Water Commission’s final report recommended
“greater water reuse and rainwater
harvesting schemes in both household and non-household markets”
and “incentivising water efficiency
through changes to wholesale tariffs
for industrial users”. If tariffs move,
payback periods move with them.
But the attention is on rain. The water leaving a process stage, which
on most sites is the cheaper and
steadier litre, is the part nobody’s
writing policy for.
Price will move industrial reuse
before regulation does, and the sites
that have already mapped what
leaves each stage will benefit first.
What to do before that
Audit what leaves each stage and
at what quality. It’s the first thing
we look at on any site we survey,
and it’s usually where the cheapest litre is. Size any reuse for the
demand that exists today, not the
demand a drought might create.
Start with the lowest-quality use
and the stream that already meets
it. And put someone’s name on the
water between stages, because
until it has an owner it will keep going to drain.
Tariff reform may or may not
arrive before the next drought. The
water leaving each stage of the
plant is there either way. TWR
November 2026
41