TWR Nov 2026_ebook - Flipbook - Page 37
ENVIRONMENT|INDUSTRY COMMENT
INDUSTRY COMMENT
NORFOLK BROADSIDE
The first nutrient EDP would allow
development to add nitrogen and
phosphorus to already stressed
protected waters. Dr Gabriel ConnorStreich urges scrutiny before the
approach is repeated elsewhere.
The first nutrient Environmental
Delivery Plan (EDP), which was
consulted on last month, is not just
a Norfolk planning consultation. It
is the first live test of a new national
approach to dealing with nutrient
pollution from development in
protected waters.
The plan would allow development to add nitrogen and
phosphorus to already stressed
protected waters while broader
ecological measures are used
to demonstrate ‘overall improvement’. Natural England is preparing
16 nutrient EDPs across England.
Norfolk is first, covering the Broads
and River Wensum, and Natural
England describes the consultation
as an opportunity to help shape
the relationship between nature
recovery and development across
the country. What is accepted here
will therefore matter well beyond
these catchments.
From nutrient mitigation to
‘overall improvement’
I have spent years working with
Natural England on the quantitative
science behind nutrient neutrality, including its nutrient-budgeting
approach and nature-based
mitigation. Under the current nutrient
neutrality model, additional nitrogen
or phosphorus generated by a
development is calculated, and sufficient mitigation secured ahead of
construction, so that the protected
site does not receive a higher nutrient load and nutrient concentrations are not increased further.
I saw an earlier version of the Norfolk EDP. That draft had problems
THE UK WATER REPORT
around pricing, procurement and
payment, but it retained something
fundamental: development’s additional nutrient pollution was quantified and the proposed interventions
were intended to provide quantifiable nutrient reductions.
The published version takes a materially different approach. It applies
a new Overall Improvement Test.
Natural England must show that the
positive effects of the conservation
measures, taken together, materially
outweigh the negative effects of
the maximum development covered by the plan. The measures do
not have to remove an equivalent
quantity of the nitrogen or phosphorus that development adds to
the catchment.
The measures proposed have
ecological value. Fen restoration,
land-use change, river restoration
and deer management can all be
good things for nature. But they do
not make additional nitrogen or
phosphorus disappear.
Analysis of Natural England’s published figures by Alexa Culver, legal
counsel at RSK Wilding, estimates
that development under the Norfolk
plan would still result in an additional
7,695kg of nitrogen entering protected waterways each year – 83% of
the development load – alongside
The claim
of ‘overall
improvement’
starts to look
uncomfortably
like greenwashing.
up to 435kg of additional phosphorus. Natural England nevertheless
concludes that the wider package
of conservation measures constitutes
“Overall Improvement”.
That is a profound change in what
we mean by dealing with nutrient
pollution and, more broadly, in what
may constitute impact management
from new development. The new
model is not requiring that pollution
be avoided, neutralised or mitigated.
It allows much of the additional
nutrient load to remain and relies on
totally different ecological improvements to outweigh the harm overall.
In my view, that is where the claim
of ‘overall improvement’ starts to
look uncomfortably like greenwashing. Creation, restoration and management of protected ecosystems
will do little if pillars of ecosystem
health such as nutrient concentrations are at dangerous levels.
Pollution and solution
timetables
Internal Defra correspondence
obtained by Greenshank under
the Environmental Information
Regulations reveals a fundamental
timing problem in the new system.
Officials anticipate a one-to-twoyear gap between developments
entering the Nature Restoration
Fund and the corresponding levy
income arriving to pay for conservation measures.
A developer can begin work after
paying only the first instalment of the
levy whilst Natural England is responsible for securing and delivering the
conservation. The model therefore
separates the point at which development can proceed from the point
at which all of the developer money
intended to fund its environmental
response is available.
Defra has already had to bridge
that gap. It has confirmed that
£11.5m of public money was provided to Natural England in 2026/27
specifically for expenditure required
ahead of levy receipts. That figure
confirms the problem is not theoretical: the new system already relies on
Dr Gabriel ConnorStreich, CEO and
principal environmental
scientist, Greenshank
Environmental
Government fronting the cost while
it waits for developer payments to
catch up – and the taxpayer is currently carrying the gap.
Norfolk needs to provide a
proper test
There is a way of doing strategic
catchment mitigation well. Pooling
developer contributions could fund
larger, better coordinated interventions. Nature-based measures
can reduce nutrient loads while
improving habitat, biodiversity,
flood resilience and water quality.
The science exists to quantify many
of those interventions.
But strategic delivery should not
mean abandoning the quantitative link between an environmental
impact and the measures intended
to deal with it.
The Norfolk consultation explicitly
asked for views on the evidence,
the proposed conservation measures and how the plan can be
strengthened. This is the point to
interrogate whether the plan actually deals with the nutrient pollution
it permits, whether its measures are
capable of delivering the claimed
improvement and whether the levy
is sufficient – and sufficiently timely
– to deliver them.
If the template does not change,
we risk embedding a model in which
additional pollution is accepted, different ecological benefits are used
to compensate for it, and public
money bridges the gap while levy
receipts catch up.
This might start in Norfolk, but the
consequences will not stay there. TWR
November 2026
37