TWR Nov 2026_ebook - Flipbook - Page 29
INDUSTRY COMMENT|PLANNING
INDUSTRY COMMENT
REGIONAL POWER, BUT
NO SINGLE BLUEPRINT
James Cattermole observes that the
geography of government is changing,
but the need to plan around the
geography of water will endure.
Since becoming prime minister,
Andy Burnham has made devolution central to his agenda, and this
creates an opportunity to bring
water and growth planning more
closely together. It seems nonsensical that a region can have an ambitious growth strategy, sites allocated for housing and businesses ready
to invest, yet no agreed timetable
for the water infrastructure that
makes those plans possible. By the
time the gap becomes apparent,
the land commitments, development programmes and investment
decisions that depend on future
capacity can stall. Frustratingly, this
is far from an isolated problem.
Stronger regional leadership
could help prevent that mismatch.
But water planning cannot simply
adopt the geography or institutions
of devolved government. Its success
will depend on connecting several
overlapping systems, with enough
authority to resolve competing
priorities and enough flexibility to
reflect local circumstances.
The lesson from Manchester
Inevitably we read a lot about
Greater Manchester’s experience
of devolution and this offers a useful starting point. Its approach to
devolution rests on collaboration
between councils and the coordination of housing, transport, skills
and investment around a shared
economic vision. The principle
behind contemporary ‘Manchesterism’ is that regional leaders
can use their understanding of an
area’s strengths to create better
conditions for growth.
For water, the application is
more practical than visionary.
THE UK WATER REPORT
Decisions about new communities
and employment locations should
be informed by supply, treatment
capacity and environmental constraints from the outset. Water investment should, in turn, reflect credible
development programmes.
Other regions need the ability to
establish that relationship in ways
suited to their economies and institutions. Greater Manchester’s collaborative approach offers lessons, but
its particular arrangements cannot
be assumed to work everywhere.
and development planning closer
together. Although regional water
resources planning already exists,
the challenge is to connect that
work more effectively with wastewater, spatial planning and investment decisions. Reform should
clarify which organisations decide
priorities, how disagreements are
resolved and how those decisions
influence funding.
That also means aligning longterm infrastructure needs with
shorter investment and political
cycles. A regional plan should show
which interventions are essential
now, which depend on future
demand and what evidence would
trigger a change of approach.
Common standards,
different responses
Water exposes the limits of administrative boundaries: a mayoral area
may contain parts of several river
catchments; a water company
can serve multiple strategic authorities; supply networks, wastewater
treatment catchments and flood
risks each have their own geography; while reservoirs and transfers
may support development far from
where the infrastructure is located.
Yet when a council is allocating
employment land, say for an industrial cluster, the authority promoting
regional growth and the company
forecasting water demand may
each be working to different assumptions and timescales.
Regional leadership should make
those differences visible early, provide a route to resolving them and
also recognise interests beyond its
own boundary.
The Environment Agency’s National
Framework for Water Resources
identifies a potential public water
supply deficit of up to 5bn litres a
day in England by 2055 under a
‘do nothing’ scenario. Providing for
growth must go alongside reducing damaging abstraction and
improving resilience.
Pressures differ regionally;
agricultural demand, constrained
water sources, urban drainage and
treatment capacity call for different
combinations of investment and
demand management. Additional
storage may be essential in one
location; reducing surface water
entering sewers may offer greater
value in another. Regional flexibility
must work with national standards.
The White Paper cites Severn
Trent’s work with farmers to reduce
pollutants entering water sources,
avoiding expensive treatment
infrastructure. Such approaches
demonstrate why regional plans
must consider land management
alongside engineering.
Connecting the plans
Institutional uncertainty
The government’s January 2026
water White Paper proposed an
enhanced regional planning
function that brings water, flood
The pause in local government reorganisation adds a complication.
The government says its devolution
timetable remains unchanged
Several geographies, one
delivery challenge
James Cattermole is a
partner at Carter Jonas.
and unitary councils are not a
prerequisite for strategic authorities.
Nevertheless, uncertainty about future structures could absorb officer
capacity, complicate relationships
and weaken the continuity needed
for regional decisions. Water planning cannot wait for every institutional question to be settled.
This is particularly important
where regions have less established
collaborative institutions than
Greater Manchester. A framework
for devolution creates opportunities,
but the ability to use them depends
on expertise, resources and sustained cooperation.
From ambition to consent
From our point of view, the test
is whether these arrangements
create deliverable programmes.
A strategic priority needs land, a
consenting route, environmental
evidence, community engagement and an achievable construction timetable.
Regional leadership should bring
the relevant parties together early,
establish who owns each dependency and provide escalation
where competing priorities cannot
be reconciled. Companies and
regulators retain their responsibilities;
regional political leadership should
help connect those responsibilities
with the development decisions
that shape future demand.
Success would mean investment
being available to support planned
growth and better environmental
outcomes, with fewer commitments
resting on uncertain capacity. The
geography of government is changing, but the need to plan around the
geography of water will endure. TWR
November 2026
29