TWR Nov 2026_ebook - Flipbook - Page 28
FEATURE|OWNERSHIP
Reform controlled councils vying with more conventionally run
councils. Presumably, water utilities would not be allowed to
manage let alone mitigate climate change.
Local accountability is seen as a driver behind the possibility
of local authority control. In a way, this would go back to the
Water Authority model of 1974-84, when local councils had a
number of nominated board members. It was appreciated that
having Mayors play a role has a certain simplicity to it. It was
also appreciated that there are some areas with a great deal more
elected mayors than others. What could be a powerful model in
some areas, might have a minimal impact in areas with a comparative paucity of major cities, especially across southern England let alone Wales. Direct government ownership would be a
great deal more straightforward.
Regulation and affordability
The presenters who were arguing for public ownership stated
that when you have public ownership, there is no need for a regulator. This is contradicted by the Scottish experience. Likewise,
no mention was made about how long-term planning (such as
balancing supplies and demand, let alone cleaning up rivers and
coasts) is meant to happen. It was difficult to know where principles are meant to encounter practicalities. There was long term
planning in the 1960s to 1980s, yet the pressures were wholly
different to those we now face.
Considering utilities and affordability, it was noted that in the
Netherlands, it is the role of social security to intervene where
people struggle to pay their utility bills. Being public-sector
owned, this is a more seamless process than in England and
Wales.
the absence of urban areas is a factor in determining coverage.
Actual deployment is very much a work in
progress. EDMs were monitored for 2.5% of the time
in 2025, with 20% not operating at all. England and
Wales are now at 100% EDM coverage following a
concerted monitoring rollout programme.
More distant shores
Looking globally, I pointed out other approaches. In Singapore,
the PUB welcomes private management and investment where it
offers appropriate efficiencies.
Germany, France, Spain and Italy provide a range of hybrid
approaches, with differing levels of private management, while
Scandinavia demonstrates where state held entities charge aggressively enough to make demand management the norm.
Finally, there is Chile where services and infrastructure have
been transformed from those seen in a developing economy to a
northern European level of delivery.
Closing observations
Differences of opinion and interpretation were inevitable in the
session. What was intriguing was the essential tension between
those calling for the sector’s renationalisation and the way this
would be brought about. Scottish Water was constantly cited as a
public ownership exemplar, yet its evolution over the past three
decades has taken it away from the local authority approach,
into an integrated national model, within a formal regulatory
framework based on a formal series of six-year asset management plans. Where does this fit in with an (in effect) unregulated
(legal standards and so on notwithstanding) collective of local
authority-controlled entities?
At the same time, support for the current state of affairs was
tepid at best. Continued private sector ownership can only be
justified under a fundamentally redrawn regulatory settlement
from 2030. Here, it will be interesting to see what hybrid offerings are suggested, especially in introducing fresh layers of accountability, which were teasingly hinted at in Cunliffe. TWR
2027. Scottish Water is tantalisingly close to this,
which would be a notable achievement. There are
no updated figures for Wales or Scotland, while in
2025, the headline good to high figure fell to 14.3%
in England.
Drinking water monitoring is similar and equally
effective. Anecdotal evidence suggests that
SEPA’s water monitoring, advisory and enforcement capacity is stronger than at the Environment
Agency and Natural Resources Wales.
❙ Regulatory climate – WICS has in effect the same
role as Ofwat in England and Wales, although
its reporting requirements are lighter. There have
been no Annual Performance Reports in the public domain in recent years.
What Scottish Water tells us
WICS (Scottish Water’s performance, 2024-25)
❙ Bathing water – Table 1 shows bathing areas as
notes that Scottish Water outperforms the English
designated under the revised EU Bathing Waters
and Welsh companies in terms of water supply
Directive. The underperformance in Scotland is nointerruptions, pollution incidents and internal sewer
table, especially in the context of its Water
flooding. It underperforms these companies
Framework Directive (WFD) performance.
with regards to leakage reduction, per capita
TABLE 1: COASTAL AND INLAND BATHING
There is indirect evidence that some of
water consumption and discharge permit
WATER QUALITY CLASSIFICATIONS, 2025 DATA
the English and Welsh water companies
compliance.
may well be ‘gaming’ the system since
This in essence sums up the situation. NeiNumber
Poor Sufficient
Good Excellent
testing dates can be predicted and sewer
ther is better or worse per se. Some of the
449
7.1%
5.6%
21.2%
66.1%
England
discharges timed to avoid these.
differences in performance reflect the differ110
1.8%
5.5%
21.8%
70.9% ent operating, geographical and demoWales
❙ Water Framework Directive – For reasons
graphic circumstances. For example, popuScotland
89
3.4%
14.6%
29.2%
52.8%
good and bad, human intervention in
lation growth in Scotland since 1990 has
much of Scotland’s rivers, lakes and coasts
been 9%, compared with 11% in Wales and
TABLE 2: WFD COMPLIANCE IN ENGLAND,
is minimal when compared with Wales, let
23% in England. The evidence suggests that
WALES AND SCOTLAND, 2009-22
alone England. These are rivers that sing in
even after the recent poor performance of
an otherworldly silence, so to speak. But
2009
2015
2022 the English and Welsh companies, they are
the same WFD assessment criteria apply.
at least equal with Scottish Water. In a British
24.9%
19.8%
15.7%
England – Good to high
The fall in England is in contrast to both
context, as matters stand, company per29.9%
38.1%
40.4% formance under state ownership appears
Wales and Scotland (see table 2). The origi- Wales – Good to high
nal aim of the WFD was to see 70% of these
Scotland – Good to high
61.1%
62.4%
64.2% to be neither appreciably better nor worse
waters reaching at least ‘good’ status by
than private sector ownership.
28
November 2026
THE UK WATER REPORT