TWR Nov 2026_ebook - Flipbook - Page 27
OWNERSHIP|FEATURE
The third session saw academics associated with renationalisation campaigns pitted against the CEO of Water
UK. It was of a distinctly feistier nature than the earlier
two. Indeed, personal opinions and (as far as I could see)
some selectively used data was not particularly helpful when
seeking to inform MPs as to realities rather than particular
points of view.
Thames Water did not feature, as the Committee concluded in
September that the company ought to have been placed under a
Special Administration Regime some time ago.
Not-for-profit push
One intriguing element was the companies considering adopting
a not-for-profit model post Ofwat’s 1999 Periodic Review. Along
with Glas Cymru (which had the benefit of a devolved political
settlement with the recently formed Welsh Senedd to report to),
it was well known that Yorkshire Water sought a similar model
which was blocked by Ofwat and they were afterwards embraced
by the tender mercies of private equity. I did not appreciate that
Southern and Anglian also sought this approach, which again
was rebuffed. Like Yorkshire, they were subsequently bought out
by private equity. This says a lot about Ofwat’s 1999, where regulatory overreach (12% one-off price cuts and maintained spending levels) was in most cases seen as incompatible with life as
listed equities.
There was also some curiosity about how Glas Cymru recruits
its external members. From my experience in 2001, it is not
seeking to be a representative group per se, as it is up to people to come forward to be appointed. In theory, it can have 200
members; in reality there are 47 at present. There was also some
concern about why the not-for-profit model was not resulting
in strong overall performance. I observed that the new CEO of
Glas Cymru (who previously ran the state-owned Sydney Water)
thought Glas’s comparative travails owe more to the regulatory
framework than its particular business model.
cost of all domestic water and sewerage services
was £7.40 per cubic meter of water in Glasgow,
against £5.95 in Birmingham (Severn Trent), £6.00
in London (Thames) and £6.43 in Cardiff (Dŵr
Cymru). Scottish Water charges by property
value, as it has almost no metered customers.
❙ Metering – 1% of domestic properties are metered
in Scotland, against 66% in England and Wales in
2026 (12% with smart meters in 2025, set to rise to
75% by 2040). Scottish Water is currently carrying out
a smart water metering trial in Dundee and has already identified a more significant degree of within
household leakage than previously anticipated.
Given most of Scotland’s abundant water
resources, this may not have been a concern, yet
the vulnerabilities exposed in the 2025 drought
suggest this may matter on a regional level.
❙ Leakage – Between 2021-22 and 2025-26, leakage was between 453Ml/day and 462Ml/day
for Scottish Water. This is materially below where
it was a decade ago. In percentage terms, this
was 25% in 2024-25 against a weighted average
THE UK WATER REPORT
Governance and finance
General themes to emerge as well as ownership included aspects
of finance, governance and accountability.
The Water Industry Commission for Scotland (WICS) is
seen as having an appreciably less combative relationship with
Scottish Water than Ofwat has with the English and Welsh
water companies. Intriguingly, Sir Ian Byatt was both director
general of Ofwat (1989-00) and chairman of WICS (2005-11).
Perhaps the most telling point emerging was the focus on
the cost of servicing private sector debt as a percentage of revenues, especially in comparing those in England and Wales
with Scotland. Ofwat’s desired 55% gearing target may ultimately reduce this both by improving debt ratings and debt
loadings. That will be driven by the efficient delivery of new
assets. There is also the question about whether the public or
private sectors are better at raising the funding that will be
needed by 2050.
Local accountability
There was quite a bit of support for local authorities to run water services. This is a fascinating idea, as it goes away from the
catchment-based approach back to one with a number of potentially conflicting local concerns. It will also be interesting to see
how local politicians are able to interpret long term water and
wastewater policies and priorities. If the local authorities have
shares in the utilities, this could have quite a range of outcomes
as to how these shares are allocated between the various entities within each regional area. For example, large areas within a
catchment will have a low population density, and presumably, a
low percentage of overall share ownership, yet a high impact in
terms of water resources and impacts from, for example, agricultural sources.
When you have municipal ownership, it was pointed out that
you will need a coalition of municipal shareholders to get policies enacted. This can be a fraught process. Imagine one or two
of 20% for England and Wales. Anecdotally, it can
still be 40% in parts of western Scotland.
Leakage is an emotive subject, as losing
treated water within a network is rightly regarded
as an unacceptable indulgence. While 20% leakage is deemed acceptable, for example in the
USA, in Germany, Denmark and Singapore, 6-10%
is seen as a suitable level. Does leakage matter?
Perhaps not in western Scotland. Even so, it is a
‘noisy’ headline, especially when reservoirs may
start to run dry, and there is intense pressure to
further reduce leakage in England and Wales.
❙ Customer satisfaction – Scottish Water has the
highest customer satisfaction ratings of all water
utilities in the UK. This at least in part reflects different expectations under public and private
ownership. It is also evident that media coverage
in Scotland is more appreciative. Scottish Water
also often leads in the annual British Water survey
of goods and services supplier satisfaction.
❙ Discharge permit compliance – Scottish Water
has a 96.90% compliance rate for sewage
treatment works discharges against 98.81% for
England and Wales. Given the recent controversies about company self-reporting in this aspect in
England and Wales, these numbers may be open
to debate.
❙ Drinking water – Between 2021-22 and 2025-26,
drinking water quality has met 99.92-99.93% of all
applicable WHO related drinking water criteria
in Scotland. The figure for England and Wales
is 99.97%. In a global context, this difference is
trivial. Putting it simply, Great Britain enjoys the
best drinking water quality in any medium sized
countries in the world.
❙ Event duration monitoring – The number of
EDMs in Scotland rose from 1,000 in 2004 to 1,287
in 2025. The emphasis has been on monitoring
bathing waters. It is interesting to note that Scottish Water is already using volumetric measurement at some storm overflows (SOs). This means
that the actual flow from a number of SOs can
be calculated through combining event duration and discharge volume. In much of Scotland,
November 2026
27