TWR Nov 2026_ebook - Flipbook - Page 26
FEATURE|OWNERSHIP
UNLOCKING
OWNERSHIP
OPTIONS
David Lloyd Owen
reflects on his
evidence session to
the EFRA Committee
on water ownership
models.
W
hen they are televised, appearances at the various House of Commons’ select committees
can be characterised as exercises in political
theatrics as MPs seek to expose the evasive. In
contrast, the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee’s meeting on the future ownership status of the English and
Welsh water companies was a model of restraint, with the six
MPs asking a useful series of questions which spurred some
detailed and interesting responses. It was in effect, apolitical,
driven by curiosity rather than putting across points of view.
It was also evident that the MPs had been most well briefed.
I gave evidence in the first session, and concentrated on what
the Glas Cymru experience tells us, Scottish Water as a comparator (see other section), international insights, public trust in
privatised utilities, the point that climate change and population
growth were not seen as concerns at the time of privatisation,
and the impact of the ownership models on the English water
companies. The one area that was not covered thoroughly was
why the sector was privatised in the first place. It was a busy session.
SCOTTISH WATER AS A COMPARATOR
In the popular imagination, western Scotland
enjoys abundant water resources (in particular,
through supplies to Glasgow from Loch Katrine),
yet significant parts of eastern Scotland are
vulnerable to drought. This was noticeable in 2025,
when some reservoirs were at 21-30% of capacity.
Scottish Water was formed in 2002 from three regional water entities (which in turn had previously
been eleven yet more local undertakings), which
means in terms of operating as an integrated
service provider, it had 28 years (the 1974 rationalisation of water and sewerage undertakings in
England and Wales) or 13 years (privatisation in
1989) of catching up to do at the time, depending on your perspective. As it (broadly) uses the
same regulatory models as England and Wales,
Scotland is a useful comparator.
Here, information for south of the border has
been taken from the Environment Agency, Natural
Resources Wales, Drinking Water Inspectorate and
Ofwat data, along with the company Annual
26
November 2026
Performance Reports. For Scotland, data is used
from WICS, the Scottish Environmental Protection
Agency and Scottish Water’s annual report for
2025-26.
❙ Capital spending – It is often mentioned that per
capita capital spending is higher in Scotland than
it is in England and Wales. While that may have
been the case in earlier years, it is no longer so.
In 2025-26, per capita capital spending in
England and Wales was £184 against £161 for
Scotland on a comparable basis. This reflects
capital spending in England and Wales being
expected to rise by 71% in AMP8 (2025-30) against
AMP7 (2020-25), as the companies move out of
a ‘cheap and nasty’ era. For 2027-33 planned
capital spending for Scottish Water is on average
£1.35bn per annum (£251 per capita) against an
average of £20.75bn per annum for England and
Wales in 2025-30 (£329 per capita), which suggests the gap is set to widen further.
❙ Finance – Scottish Water has £5,044m in loans
from the Scottish Government at an average interest of 3.2%, or a net £157m in financing costs during
2025-26. With net assets of £7,204m, gearing was
70% and net debt servicing was 9.0% of revenues.
By comparison, typical debt service costs in England and Wales range from 20-30% of revenues.
While gearing is high (Ofwat recommends a ceiling of 65%, which is moving to 55%) this is mitigated
by a lower cost of capital, due to the Scottish Government having an initial AA debt rating (awarded
by S&P in 2025) while the average debt rating for
the water companies is BBB. After privatisation, the
average debt rating in England and Wales was AA,
which Ofwat subsequently considered to be unnecessarily high. An AA rating would make a material
difference today, especially as interest rates have
risen from their post 2008 financial crisis lows.
❙ Tariffs – According to the Global Water Intelligence water tariff survey, in 2025 the average
THE UK WATER REPORT