TWR Nov 2026_ebook - Flipbook - Page 21
WATER RESOURCES|FEATURE
His advice is two-fold. First, the forthcoming Clean Water Bill
should include water security provisions – including resilience
standards – to give legislative backing to this priority. “So there’s
always the counter, when someone says ‘you need to turn that
abstraction down’ to say ‘but that means I breach the water security directive’.
Second, Hinton believes the Water Framework Directive itself
should be reviewed and updated. He argues that it uses legacy
numbers and crude measures based around flow to determine
how much abstraction the water environment can support, not
sophisticated measures of actual environmental health. It should
“be more environmentally-based in terms of outcome, using biodiversity measures, habitat measures and the like.” After all, high
flow does not guarantee good ecology.
These changes should be made before the new integrated regulator gets going. “The new regulator, if underpinned by the same
legislation and therefore incentives, will produce a similar outcome to what we have now.”
3. Revamp regulatory duties and approach
That takes us neatly on to wider regulatory matters. Hinton argues
the new regulator should have a specific duty for water security. In
that capacity, it should take a more active position in co-creating water supply options with the water companies rather than, at present,
identifying deficits and then judging options the industry comes up
with to address them. Collective optioneering, he believes, would
create more opportunities than those typically reached for today
(less leakage, demand reduction, increased supply).
He points out: “The Environment Agency knows a lot about
where you can take water from the environment.” Resourcing
catchment solutions such re-meandering rivers that would improve flow and ecology could support licensed abstractions to be
increased. Similarly, supporting more localised on-farm storage,
such as for fruit growers, could help flatten summer peaks.
The planned shift away from one-size-fits-all regulation should
help. “The biggest thing Ofwat needs to do is treat companies individually. Using collective models, single WACCs, all that stuff
ends up isolating some companies who just happen to be on the
wrong end of that model, or who have a stress on them that no
one else has got.”
A further point is that the regulatory system must be made to be
more open to acknowledging its own shortcomings. Hinton perceives the current situation thus: “The Environment Agency sets
the water budget and Ofwat sets the financial budget. They also
set the targets. They then assess whether the company has met the
targets. And if they don’t, they then have the powers to investigate
that as poor performance. But because of their role in the earlier
part of the process, they’re never going to conclude that insufficient resource has been allocated, because that’s their job.”
4. Reform abstraction
Hinton has a hunch that more water would be available to abstract
sustainably, if the licensing regime was modernised. In many cases,
licensed volumes and arrangements are based on historic needs,
that have simply become entrenched. Meanwhile, WFD requirements make adjusting these upwards “almost impossible”.
He explains: “As a really simple example, if you built a treatment
works about 20 years ago, and you said ‘I want to take 9 megalitres
out of this river,’ that goes in the licence, bang! And then, if you
THE UK WATER REPORT
ever exceed that, you go down the enforcement process.” But as
noted above, he argues permitted volumes should relate to environmental harm and be tailored to the catchment, not based on
simple surrogates such as flow – and certainly should not just be
a product of history. “It’s almost a very hard non-environmental
number being used to pseudo protect the environment.”
Other problems include a ratcheting down effect where licences are reduced if they are not used in full for a given period, and
an analogue approach where digitisation would enable dynamism, including to facilitate trading and therefore optimisation.
Hinton points out, too, that this archaic and sub-optimal approach to abstraction licensing has massive financial and wider
environmental implications, if you consider the biggest driver
behind the £50bn strategic resource programme is sustainability
reductions.
5. Be realistic about demand reduction
Hinton has no problem with stretching targets on leakage and
consumption. He agrees they focus the mind and are supported
by customers. But he stresses that targets should not be treated as
forecasts and baked in to Water Resources Management Plans,
unless there is evidence they are being achieved.
At the moment, that just isn’t the case. Water Resources South
East’s 2025/26 monitoring of its 2025-75 regional plan shows
leakage increased over the year and is higher than forecast for all
water companies. Non-household demand also increased across
the region. Per capita consumption fell and was slightly lower
than forecast, but the picture is mixed, with some water companies out- and others under-performing.
He reflects: “If the targets are used as forecasts and demand is
higher than the planning has planned for, the result is immediate
customer impact and insufficient investment to protect future
customers as the supply demand balance tightens. This has happened for a decade and is the single biggest contribution to the
current weak water security position. The guidelines proposed
for the next planning cycle repeat the same mistake.”
He endorses the recommendation of the old National Infrastructure Commission, that demand management risk should be
hedged by infrastructure build in parallel. “The worst thing that
happens in that world is you do achieve the demand reductions
and you build the infrastructure a bit early. So effectively the
jeopardy is a bit of early spend, whereas the jeopardy the other
way round is you run out of water.”
6. Collaborate around a common objective
Hinton concludes that water security ultimately needs stakeholders to collaborate in recognition that they have a shared objective.
“This requires a joint approach, all aiming to achieve the water
security outcomes, instead of setting unachievable, unjustified targets, prioritising the environment over all things, refusing investment and then criticising and investigating companies when the
system fails.” TWR
If you wait for the whole thing to land
before putting resilience standards
in place, that’s at least one more price
review too late.
November 2026
21