TWR Nov 2026_ebook - Flipbook - Page 20
FEATURE|WATER RESOURCES
STEPS TO
WATER
SECURITY
David Hinton has been on
the sharp end of security of
supply problems. He reflects
on the essential ingredients
for a more resilient system.
T
he fragility of our water supply system has been laid bare
this year. We entered spring with resources at nigh on
100% capacity after a very wet winter. Then followed
prolonged heat and little rain.
Now we are in autumn, pockets of the country are in severe
drought and a number of reservoirs’ raw water stocks are dangerously depleted. We are entirely dependent on winter rainfall
to get us back to square one by spring.
The system seems to be designed around weather patterns that
have ceased to be stable, and for circumstances of the past rather
than the present.
So what should be done? During his time as chief executive of
South East Water, David Hinton frequently made the case for more
investment in, and action on, water security. Repeated outages – as
his local system struggled with everything from freeze thaw bursts
and treatment plant problems to heat-driven demand surges – combined with associated political and media pressure to eventually
lead to his resignation. So, on reflection, what does he think needs
to happen to secure supplies for the south east and beyond?
Hinton offers the following reflections on steps to water security.
1. Set a policy objective for water security, pegged
to resilience standards
Water security should be a clearly defined policy objective, and
a key plank of a new national water strategy that also addresses
how any necessary trade-offs should be made.
Defining a secure water system would be best done in reference to national resilience standards. There are plenty of standards in the sector. But there are also gaps. For instance, there
is no requirement to store a certain volume of treated water per
10,000 people supplied, or to have a Plan B supply source for
populations over a certain size.
The absence of resilience-related design standards causes serious problems. Some areas have a lot of capacity while others operate with less than 5% headroom. Resilience investment is also
treated as discretionary, and as such is vulnerable to suppression.
Defra’s Water White Paper committed to implement resilience
standards as part of the reform agenda. Hinton urges that these
20
November 2026
be operationalised promptly and effectively. The standards he
would prioritise concern:
❙ Storage – this could be, say, 24 or 48 hours worth at peak demand.
That would buy a defined amount of time in the event of short term
issue, such as a treatment works problem or power failure.
❙ Connectivity – this relates to addressing the single source of
supply issue, but also to enabling water to be moved around in
the event of an asset failing, or between areas of lower and higher demand, which may change at different times of the week,
month or year.
❙ Water production capacity compared to demand – production capacity should exceed peak demand by a set minimum
proportion, to help cope with demand-led incidents like those
witnessed this summer and to allow the systems to recover, reducing the impact on customers.
Hinton notes the reservations about introducing resilience standards. In particular, it could necessitate costly investment in areas
where resilience is exposed to be lacking. But with this summer’s
weather exposing more and more areas to be vulnerable the issue
is becoming more pressing. The costs of not acting must be considered alongside the costs of investing in a more robust system.
He also believes standards would reveal data containing opportunities to share water more effectively. Areas with high resilience could be connected to areas of low resilience. “All it needs
is a willingness to create and share the standards,” he says.
He urges policymakers to prioritise action here, even if wider
water reform is delayed. “If you wait for the whole thing to land
before putting resilience standards in place, that’s at least one
more price review too late.” He believes it is the single biggest
thing the new regulator can deliver for customers.
2. Enshrine water security in legislation
Hinton says there is a severe imbalance between the robust legislation that underpins environmental obligations (Water Framework Directive and Habitats Directive), and the lack of legislation to underpin water security. The latter relies on Outcome
Delivery Incentives to drive action. In a trade-off situation, this
is seriously imbalanced.
THE UK WATER REPORT