TWR Nov 2026_ebook - Flipbook - Page 18
INDUSTRY COMMENT|PLANNING
INDUSTRY COMMENT
WATER REFORM NEEDS
MORE THAN A NEW MAP
Moving decisions closer to
communities will not, alone, bring
legitimacy. Penny Hodge champions
meaningful participation.
Regional systems planning offers a
rare opportunity to connect water
investment with growth and environmental priorities. But redrawing
the map will not, by itself, rebuild
public trust. Legitimacy will depend
on clear accountability, meaningful participation and a visible link
between evidence and decisions.
The Independent Water Commission recommended regional
water authorities are established
to support integrated water system
planning and investment plans
shaped by local needs and voices.
However, moving decisions about
water closer to communities and
giving local leaders more power in
the process will not, on its own, make
those decisions more legitimate.
As the government considers the
implementation of regional groups
through an early, non-statutory roll out
ahead of PR29, they must be clear
about their role and the decisions
they will make, which responsibilities
will remain with water companies
and regulators, and who will be accountable for final decisions.
Regional groups could be led by
mayors or independent chairs and
include stakeholders and experts
from water management, spatial
planning, agriculture, industry and
other major water-using sectors. The
aim is that they fill the ‘missing middle’
between national priorities and local
delivery by reflecting regional needs
in water investment decisions.
However, if the public do not
feel represented and cannot see
what they can influence, who is accountable and why choices have
been made, reform risks relocating mistrust rather than resolving
it. In addition to considering the
18
November 2026
appropriate governance, structure,
process and funding for the new
regional groups, the government
must also consider how the public
can participate in the process and
inform the decisions that are made.
In the early roll out, the regional
groups will be working with the existing statutory processes that exist to
inform investment in water resources,
drainage and wastewater. Extensive
engagement and participation are
already underway to inform these
plans, ahead of the formal consultation required, which the groups will
need to take account of in the decisions that they make.
In the longer term, there is considerable scope for change. The
government has already set a wider
objective to scale back the number
of consultations undertaken and
are considering repealing many existing consultations that currently sit
on the statute book. In its Rewiring
the state policy paper it states it will
“replace the current model of consultation by default with new and
modern forms of public participation” and that includes “considering
where performative statutory duties
to consult can be revoked and how
we can more bring the public into
the policy-making process instead”.
Therefore, in the longer term, with
the existing water-related plans due
to be rationalised into two planning
frameworks alongside the establishment of statutory regional groups,
current consultation requirements
will also need to be rethought.
Representation is not
participation
By their nature, regional groups will
bring stakeholders together to both
develop the plans and apportion responsibility to deliver them.
Creating the conditions for greater
and more formal collaboration
between spatial planners, major
water users, catchment partnership, technical specialists and other
infrastructure providers will be a
big step forwards in integrating
water management, supporting
sustainable growth and delivering environmental improvements.
This lends itself to genuine coproduction, where plans are jointly
designed, delivered and evaluated
and where decision making and
accountability is shared.
However, water planning involves
choices that cannot be settled by
technical evidence alone. Plans
must consider how to balance affordability with long-term resilience,
regional benefits with local impacts,
and growth with environmental
capacity. These are questions
of fairness as well as feasibility.
Establishing regional groups with
an independent chair, mayors
and public leaders involved does
build more democracy into the
decision-making process but it is not
a substitute for hearing directly from
affected communities.
Participation should not mean
asking everyone about everything.
The starting point must be the
decision - what is genuinely open
to influence, what is constrained by
If the public do not feel
represented and cannot see
what they can influence, who is
accountable and why choices have
been made, reform risks relocating
mistrust rather than resolving it.
Penny Hodge is a director
at Create 51, and a
partner in the Centre for
Consultation.
law, finance or engineering, and
who will make the final judgement? Without that clarity, even
extensive engagement can create
expectations that decision-makers
cannot meet.
Confident Consultation
The Centre for Consultation’s
Confident Consultation model
offers a practical way to connect
participation with governance. Its
logic is straightforward: define the
decision, identify whose evidence
matters, establish what needs to
be learned, choose proportionate engagement, record the
evidence, make trade-offs explicit
and explain the outcome.
For government, the priority should be clear participation
expectations alongside regional
governance arrangements: named
accountability, proportionate
engagement and a traceable link
between evidence and decisions.
For regional groups, early progress
should include showing how existing
evidence supports their choices –
not simply publishing a plan quickly.
The central challenge is not simply
to create a better planning structure.
It is to build a structure where participation is built into the decision-making process and seen as an asset,
and where public consultation is not
a final hurdle before publication. The
ambition should be better decisions
that can withstand scrutiny.
A new regional map can change
where decisions are made. Only a
credible relationship between public
input and public decisions can
change why people trust them. TWR
THE UK WATER REPORT