TWR Nov 2026_ebook - Flipbook - Page 17
PLANNING|FEATURE
see where their input has actually had an influence. Just shifting
accountability to a regional group does not create legitimacy. It’s
still got to be transparent, and people have to be clear about what
they’ve influenced and how their feedback has been taken into
account”(See Hodge's comment on the next page).
In the pilot phase, it is envisaged that WRSE will play a dual
role: continuing its regional water resource planning function;
and creating a separate new secretariat function for the PRAGs.
Gough makes it clear that the vision is for WRSE to provide a
“technical expertise secretariat, not say ‘this is how you need to
do it’…We don’t want to be a dominant voice. We just want to be
a supportive voice in that piloting phase.”
Chisholm adds: “It’s a massively complex region of the country. The two basins are really quite different. You’re going to need
a lot of expertise to be able to navigate all of that. But what has
to be made absolutely, abundantly clear is that it is a technical
function, and there is an entirely new governance structure sitting above that multi-sector regional plan. It has nothing to do
with the water companies, who are doing the the regional water
resources planning.” He likens it to the support function set up
for smaller participants in the Regional Energy Strategic Plans.
Post PR29 vision
After the price review, Arup and Frontier Economics advise the
groups should pivot to become statutory Regional Advisory Groups
(RAGs), legislated for in the forthcoming Clean Water Bill. The independent chairs should be appointed by the environment secretary, and group membership comprised as in the pilot phase – but
with clear funding routes for each stakeholder’s participation.
Chisholm explains the rationale for the statutory footing. In
research, “pretty broadly, people felt that for it to work, they
would need that heft,” – not least so participants can devote
time and resources to it where budgets are tight. Furthermore, it
would allay concerns about “the regulator being the plan-maker and also regulating the outcomes of those plans” should the
RAGs be only advisory.
In this phase, the RAGs must again be served by a technical and
administrative secretariat. The secretariat team should be funded and
employed by the regulator but accountable to the RAG itself, following the model of Regional Flood and Coastal Committees. The secretariat would collate multi-sector scheme options, and optimise these
using a common evidence base. There should be no sector-specific
targets, rather a single joined-up plan. The RAG would be presented with a set of key choices for decision. Gough advises that while
WRSE could act as a useful bridge in the pilot phase, it is wise not to
“assume WRSE is going to be there in the long-term”.
The RAGs should have the power to bring regional flexibility
to the timing and scope of national water targets, and to determine the majority of water company enhancement programmes,
with bill levels agreed jointly with the regulator and government.
Ong highlights that the choreography between RAGs and the
regulator needs to be clarified by Government. “We’ll have new
interfaces between a new single regulator that hasn’t been created
and these new bodies that haven’t been created. There’s obviously
a coordination problem there that needs to be addressed.”
Top questions will include what powers do the groups have?
Do they set the whole enhancement programme or just some
of it? Who then sets the outcome targets for water companies?
How are bill impacts managed, when regional choices do not
THE UK WATER REPORT
align directly with water company areas? How might funding be
blended together from multiple streams?
Ong offers: “I think you can envisage different models. And I
don’t think there’s clarity on this yet…you probably end up in a
world where the regional body decides quite a lot in terms of what
the enhancement programme is. The regulator probably still does
cost efficiency, also cost of capital, probably does base. And you
then stitch that together into a bill profile. It is not necessarily a
problem, but people just need to be clear about who does what.”
Launch and prospects
The team launched the report at a stakeholder workshop last month.
They summarise that the response was positive, with delegates appreciative of WRSE stepping up to offer detailed suggestions, and
a real appetite from all to make regional planning work. Strategic
authority representatives and MHCLG were enthusiastic, and there
was even talk of pressing the Government to specifically reference
water in its imminently expected devolution plan, given the need for
regional plans to align with Spatial Development Strategies.
Some questioned water company inclusion in the (P)RAGs, but
most accepted they should be part of decision making, but must
not dominate. Hodge highlights that collaborative regional planning risks being muddled with the narrative about greater public
control and in particular mayors holding water companies to account. This must be guarded against as these are separate issues.
The box sets out Arup and Frontier Economics’ asks of Defra,
to support their vision to work. The report cautions: “Without
these elements, the pilot runs the risk of not providing key learnings and having little impact on the choice of schemes.”
Gough believes the outlook is good. Defra supports the concept of pilots and has indicated an intention to provide some
funding. Further detail is anticipated soon. Ong adds the encouragement that: “Ultimately, this is about UK productivity. We
will need less money to achieve more.”
Chisholm concludes: “The litmus test of the early rollout phase
will be… that you’ve started to really solidify those cross-sectoral
relationships, and really set out how the thing is going to work
for the long term. And having done that, if you’ve still got the
same level of buy-in, then I think you’re winning.” TWR
ASKS OF DEFRA
›Support the establishment of PRAGs and an evolved WRSE as secretariat to
ensure “legitimacy, secure governance participation from senior stakeholders
across non-water sectors and build trust in the planning process. This could take
the form of a letter of support.”
›Give the PRAGs a clearly defined role in informing PR29 priorities and trade-offs.
“This gives stakeholders a clear reason to participate in the pilot and manages
expectations. This could take the form of a policy statement.”
›Require the EA (and the new regulator) to reflect the PRAGs’ views in the PR29
WINEP. “The PR29 regional planning pilot has the potential to inform the use of
future constrained discretion and should therefore be seen as a great opportunity for the EA to engage with PRAGs. Otherwise, there is a risk that the pilot for
the water environment part of the plan has little impact and does not deliver
important learnings.”
›Enable funding for the pilot studies and scheme development for other sectors.
“This could happen via a water bill levy to fund non-water company schemes or
by directing existing funding streams. Otherwise, there is a risk that the pilot cannot effectively optimise across sectors, leading to no change to the status quo.
Funding is required at speed so that planning can progress and inform PR29.”
November 2026
17