TWR Nov 2026_ebook - Flipbook - Page 12
FEATURE|ENVIRONMENT
so long to flush pollutants out (up to nine months for water entering at the north to make its way into the River Leven at the south).
It is also increasingly exposed to climate change impacts, including warming water temperatures, heatwaves and extreme rainfall.
The proposal
The ORiW study, led by Jacobs and Mott MacDonald, offers a
technically feasible solution, which has been whittled down from
70 options considered.
This involves building 138km of new sewerage network to intercept discharges from the ten wastewater works, 1800 septic tanks
and 89 package plants around the lake. The private infrastructure
serves not only homes but also hotels, campsites, farms and other
businesses. This would involve connecting around 12,800 people
A rich seam of international experience
has been tapped into as part of the
work, with Lake Annecy in France
providing particular inspiration.
Following wastewater interception, it
is now one of Europe’s cleanest lakes
and offers confidence that sensitive
environments can recover through
coordinated catchment work.
financed upfront, for recovery over
time through bill (and potentially
additional) revenue. The regulatory
model has not yet been determined, though it seems reasonable
to assume the work would qualify as
nationally significant infrastructure,
and that the expenditure could be
gated to boost confidence and
assurance.
United Utilities has indicated
a clear preference for in-house
delivery, rather than through alternative (DPC or SIPR) routes. It has
indicated, too, that it has investors
(both local pension funds and international players) ready to invest
and the supply chain capacity to
deliver. It has evidence to support
these assertions, including that is
recent equity raise was heavily
oversubscribed; AMP8 is on track;
and it has just been nominated
by the supply chain as the best
English water company to work
with in British Water’s 2026 survey
(see p34).
Beyond physically being able to
do it, in-house delivery offers the
advantages of being quicker and
cheaper than alternative routes.
UU’s financial strength (see p9)
attracts a highly competitive cost
of capital, which would help keep
costs down for customers. There
would be no need for long-winded
legal agreements or SPV creation,
all of which would support the vision
to get this done within seven years
from 2030. It is worth noting too that
UU is acting on experience, given
its Haweswater Aqueduct scheme
is DPC.
A broader point of interest is
that the case exposes the different suitabilities of different models
This is very clearly now a policy
decision…and that lands on
Andy Burnham’s desk.
12
November 2026
to public sewers for the first time. Much of the tunnelling work
would be done underground to minimise disruption.
The wastewater intercepted would then be transported away
to a new state-of-the-art treatment works, where discharges to
the receiving waters would be among the highest quality in Europe. There are two potential sites for this at present – via Ulverston or via the River Leven.
But the scheme goes beyond being a new super sewer; there
would be interventions across the whole catchment to deliver the
ambition of only rainwater entering the lake, including 35km of
highway runoff interception (including for all A-roads) and 37
hectares of sustainable drainage. In total, wastewater infrastructure across the catchment would increase by up to 75%.
This total catchment approach is necessary to support Windermere’s ecological recovery. Modelling forecasts up to 24 harmful algal bloom exceedance days per year in Windermere’s north
basin by 2079. Under the ORiW model, this falls to zero days.
A rich seam of international experience has been tapped into
as part of the work, with Lake Annecy in France providing particular inspiration. Following wastewater interception, it is now
one of Europe’s cleanest lakes and offers confidence that sensitive
environments can recover through coordinated catchment work.
ORiW is priced at around £3.7bn and would take seven years
from 2030 to complete, assuming funding in AMP9. This is on
top of United Utilities’ AMP8 investment of £200m to improve
wastewater infrastructure around Windermere to 2030.
As the feasibility study was published, United Utilities issued
an ‘invitation to tender’ for more detailed design work, to keep
up momentum. But the fate of ORiW really now sits in the hands
of policy and regulation (see point 7). TWR
for different companies. UU is able
to assert that in-house delivery
would be better for everyone because of its corporate strengths.
Not all companies could say the
same.
7. Over to you, policymakers
The really clever thing about the
coalition’s approach is that it has
done a lot of the hard yards in
areas that it has control of: stakeholder collaboration, innovation,
outline design, scoping investment
and proposing delivery. There
is clearly more to do. The ITT will
pursue more detailed design work
to refine the proposal, and there
would need to be more community
engagement, environmental assessment and so on.
But the partners have presented
a compelling and innovative solution that has key local stakeholder
buy-in to a problem of national
interest. The decision on whether
the press the go button now sits with
policymakers and regulators.
ORiW hosted a Parliamentary
launch last month, with a clear
ambition to find political and
regulatory support for the project.
Its cost benefit quantification
(£1.90 per £1 invested) studiously
followed Green Book rules so the
value of the work is expressed in
terms Treasury recognises. Twiddy
noted too that Lake Windermere is
basically “the beating pulse of its
economy” and its health cannot
be separated from wider economic concerns.
The prospects for ORiW look
strong. It is aligned with national
objectives for water quality, nature
recovery, climate resilience and economic growth. It would spur regional
regeneration and support local jobs.
The obvious potential sticking point
is affordability, and that may need
as creative an approach as the
engineering solution itself.
Staniek pointed out that this is
“very clearly now a policy decision…and that lands on Andy Burnham’s desk”.
THE UK WATER REPORT