TWR Nov 2026_ebook - Flipbook - Page 11
ENVIRONMENT|FEATURE
THE PROPOSED SOLUTIONS
Grasmere
Great Langdale
Skelwith
Bridge
Ambleside
Tr outbeck
Brathay
Low Wray
Bowness
Hawkshead
Common elements
Far
Sawrey
Key
Common elements
Ulverston option
Leven option
Gravity tunnel
Transfer route
Transfer route
Single rising main or
gravity network
Upgraded WwTW
Upgraded WwTW
Outfall point
Outfall point
Graythwaite
Leven option
Newby Bridge
environmentally, culturally and economically important rural landscapes in England. The catchment supports 20 sites of
special scientific interest, internationally important habitats and
species, and a £2.4bn tourist economy which attracts over 17m
visitors a year.
Yet Windermere it is blighted by nutrient load, especially from
wastewater. Its ecosystem is particularly sensitive because it takes
The feasibility study values the
economic, social and environmental benefit of the £3.7bn investment
at £7.5bn – taking in tourism, climate
resilience, job creation and more.
That’s £1.90 of benefit for every £1
invested.
4. National funding for a national
asset?
ORiW exposes a core funding question that is relevant for a number of
strategic assets currently under consideration: should only local people
pay? Traditionally, it is the customers
of the water company creating
the asset that pick up the bill – for
instance, Thames customers fund
Tideway. But there are two factors
that challenge that tradition: when
the asset will be of national significance as well as regional value; and
when the population served by the
local water company is too small for
the bill uplift to be reasonable.
Tideway arguably meets the first
criteria but not the second. In the
case of ORiW, both boxes can be
THE UK WATER REPORT
ticked. If paid-for only by United Utilities’ customers, the price tag would
be £3.17 a month per bill. Under a
national funding arrangement, it
would cost just 35p per month per
bill-payer across England.
There are live conversations going on across government on this,
as English water companies embark
on £50bn of investment in a string
of large strategic assets, mostly
reservoirs and other water resource
infrastructure. The Fens Reservoir is a
case in point. The growth of Cambridge is seen as a national priority,
so is it fair that Cambridge Water’s
tiny population should foot what will
be a substantial bill?
There are precedents for national
contributions to regional investment
in energy, and indeed in water where
for many years taxpayers funded a
£50 a year water bill rebate per South
West Water customer, to help pay for
wastewater infrastructure to clean
up the extensive bathing waters that
wrap around the Devon and Cornwall coasts.
Arrad Foot
Ulverston option
Ulverston
Windermere would be a good
place to unpack these arguments
rationally, and potentially to blend
in funding streams from other
beneficiaries, such as road users or
other tax payers.
5. Beyond compliance
ORiW would go beyond regulatory requirements in completely
eradicating wastewater pollution
from Windermere and in getting
ahead of likely tighter future controls
on emerging contaminants. It
would mark a shift from near-term
compliance towards long-term
environmental recovery at catchment scale. In the process, it would
provide what the partners call a
“blueprint for freshwater restoration:
establishing a new benchmark for
protecting and restoring nationally
important freshwater environments”.
While Windermere is obviously
special – as Beardmore said “a
unique place and it needs a unique
solution” – setting a new standard
for freshwater ecology is unlikely to
go unnoticed elsewhere. Staniek
observed: “Windermere should be
an inspiration” – and could well trigger visitors admiring its future crystal
clear waters to ask: “Why is my local
river not like this?”
6. Lessons in delivery
ORiW’s clear vision is for the
infrastructure work to be privately
This is ambitious. It is different.
But Windermere is unique, and if
we are serious about protecting it for
generations to come, we need to be
prepared to think bigger and act bolder
November 2026
11